Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Acknowledgements
- Introduction
- 1 “Innocent Witch-craft of Lights”: Developing Visual Judgment through Printed Books
- 2 “A New Visible World”: Developing a Visual Vocabulary for the Microscopic
- 3 “Nearly Resembling the Live Birds”: Collecting and Collating for the Reformation of Natural History
- 4 “These Rude Collections”: Accumulating Observations and Experiments
- Conclusion
- Bibliography
- Index
3 - “Nearly Resembling the Live Birds”: Collecting and Collating for the Reformation of Natural History
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 26 May 2022
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- Acknowledgements
- Introduction
- 1 “Innocent Witch-craft of Lights”: Developing Visual Judgment through Printed Books
- 2 “A New Visible World”: Developing a Visual Vocabulary for the Microscopic
- 3 “Nearly Resembling the Live Birds”: Collecting and Collating for the Reformation of Natural History
- 4 “These Rude Collections”: Accumulating Observations and Experiments
- Conclusion
- Bibliography
- Index
Summary
Abstract
This chapter examines the plates in Francis Willughby's Ornithology and unearths the sources used by the engravers to produce plates that nearly resembled the life, to use John Ray's phrase. While Ray asserted he was not repeating textual error put forth by his predecessors, such as Gessner and Aldrovandi, he used their illustrations as the basis for his own as well as drawings of live and dead birds that he collected. By uncovering the original sources for the illustrations, this chapter argues that greater value was placed on recognizable, printed images than on drawings collected by the author. This conclusion leads to a larger argument about the perceived truth-content of printed natural historical images in the seventeenth century.
Keywords: Francis Willughby, John Ray, Ornithology, Collecting, Ad vivum
In the Preface to the English edition of Willughby's Ornithology, John Ray described at length the visual resources available to him while he was compiling Francis Willughby's research and adding his own further investigations to it. He had known Willughby since their time at Cambridge, and Ray took on the task of compiling and supplementing his observations after his untimely death at the age of thirty-seven in 1672. Ray provided details about the manuscript collections that Willughby bought while in Strasbourg and Nuremberg as well as drawings he commissioned upon his return to England. He also listed some of the printed sources that he used: Aldrovandi, Clusius, Olina, Marggraf, Piso, and Bondt. In addition to having access to earlier printed ornithological texts and drawings, Ray consulted live and dried specimens of some of the birds he was studying. After discussing the difficulties he had communicating with the engravers from where he was working in the country at Willughby's family home, he states: “Notwithstanding the Figures, such as they are, take them all together, they are the best and truest, that is, most like the live Birds, of any hitherto engraven in Brass” (Preface, n.p.). He also described the images as “nearly resembling the live birds” on the title page. This chapter explores what it meant in seventeenth-century London to be “most like the live Birds” and to nearly resemble life by excavating the nuanced process involved in selecting the visual source material used by the engravers for the 373 images of birds included in the eighty plates that accompanied the English edition of Willughby's Ornithology (London, 1678).
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Engraving Accuracy in Early Modern EnglandVisual Communication and the Royal Society, pp. 137 - 176Publisher: Amsterdam University PressPrint publication year: 2022