Published online by Cambridge University Press: 23 May 2005
Sex steroids play a significant role in regulating the parasite load in experimental intraperitoneal Taenia crassiceps cysticercosis of male and female Balbc/anN mice. Briefly, oestrogens increase parasite loads and androgens decrease them (1) by acting directly on the parasite, favouring or hindering its reproduction, respectively, and (2) by biasing the hosts' immune response towards a parasite-permissive Th2 or a parasite-restrictive Th1 response. The infected male host also undergoes drastic endocrinological and behavioural changes that may impinge upon the course of infection, and the host's mating behaviour and its exposure to predators. In addition, at different times of infection, significant changes occur in the expression of c-fos in the host's hyppocampus, hypothalamus and preoptic area. Thus, the host's brain seems to sense and/or react to intraperitoneal infection. The physiological domains of the network affected by the infection, which classically included the hypothalamus-pituitary-axis and the immune system, must now incorporate the host's sexual hormones and other areas of the brain. The network's complex circuitry and functions may help understand some basic questions of parasitology (i.e. the hosts' sexual dimorphism in parasite infections, host-parasite specificity, heterogeneity in the course and outcome of infections at different stages of parasite and host development). The plurality of elements and the complexity of the network that regulates the host-parasite relationship also point to additional strategies for the treatment and control of infections.
The role played by sexual dimorphism of the host in parasite infections of mammals is a matter of debate regarding its generality, causes, mechanisms and consequences. We maintain that sexual dimorphism does not favour the same sex in all host-parasite relationships, nor is it always mediated only by testosterone, nor necessarily does it transit through the host's immune system (Morales-Montor et al. 2004a).
We review here in some detail our extensive work on the role of sex steroids upon parasite growth of Taenia crassiceps metacestodes when injected into the peritoneal cavity of mice (mostly BalbC/AnN mice) and in vitro. Results argue for a complex network comprising the immune, endocrinological and nervous systems of both host and parasite in the regulation of the plural outcomes of infections, some favouring male hosts and other females.
The involvement of host sexual differences in cysticercosis first appeared in a Mexican national serological survey performed on a human open-population: women were more frequently seropositive and showed higher haemagglutination titres than men (Larralde et al. 1992). In T. crassiceps experimental murine cysticercosis, female mice were shown to consistently carry larger parasite loads than males, albeit to different extents (from 1·3 to more than 10 times), in the various inbred mouse strains tested (Sciutto et al. 1991). Greater numbers of cysticerci in naturally infected female rodents had been noted previously (Addis, 1946; Beck, 1951; Esch, 2004) and had prompted the use of females as the preferred host to experimentally propagate the parasite (Freeman, 1962; Dorais and Esch, 1969) but its significance and mechanisms had to be further explored. Sexual dimorphism merited consideration because of the large sex-associated differences in parasite loads, and because of their correlation with different levels of protection after vaccination (Sciutto et al. 1991).
Most studies use the BalbC/AnN inbred strain of laboratory mice as experimental host because it has proved to be the most favorable among several mouse strains for the parasite's establishment and reproduction. Intraperitoneal T. crassiceps cysticercosis of male and female BalbC/AnN mice (Freeman, 1962; Smith, Esch and Kuhn, 1972) lends itself well to controlled and reproducible experimentation, generating numerical data of parasite loads in individual mice in a matter of weeks after infection. Its general representation of other forms of cysticercosis was later strengthened by similar results in other mouse and parasite strains (Sciutto et al. 1991), by the parasite's extensive sharing of antigens with other taennids and cestodes and by the DNA homology of T. crassiceps with T. solium (Vega et al. 2003). Also, there is emerging evidence of sex bias in naturally acquired T. solium cysticercosis of pigs (Morales et al. 2002) and of humans (Fleury et al. 2004), in human schistosomiasis (Booth et al. 2004), in human leishmaniasis (I. Becker, personal communication), in echinococcosis (Barriga and Al-Khalidi, 1991) and other parasite infections of mammals (Aguilar-Delfin et al. 2001; Nacher et al. 2003).
Simple experimental approaches, like neonatal gonadectomy and thymectomy, and/or whole body irradiation of mice previous to cysticercosis infection, suggest that both the endocrine and immune systems are involved in the hosts' sexual differences of parasite loads, when measured 30 days after infection. Orchidectomy greatly increases parasite loads while ovariectomy reduces them (Huerta et al. 1992). Oestradiol and testosterone supplementation of gonadectomized mice restores their parasite loads to normal levels (Huerta et al. 1992; Terrazas et al. 1994). Thymus function seems to hinder parasite numbers in both sexes but more so in males than in females and, thus, sexual differences tend to disappear in thymectomized mice (Bojalil et al. 1993). Likewise, irradiation favours parasite growth in both male and female mice but more so in the male hosts (Huerta et al. 1992). T cell replenishment in thymectomized male and female mice, but not passively administred mouse whole immune sera, restores parasite loads and sexual differences in favour of females in association with restoration of cutaneous delayed hypersensitivity reactions (Bojalil et al. 1993). Vaccination is more effective in male mice than in female mice, both in reducing parasite loads and in increasing the number of mice totally free of parasites (Sciutto et al. 1990). Furthermore, a Th1 response is involved in resistance to infection, whereas Th2 activity associates with heavy parasite intensities, since mice that received anti-interleukin 10 (IL-10) Ab or recombinant IL-10 carried lower parasite intensities and developed a strong Th1-type response, while mice receiving anti-interferon gamma (IFN-γ) and anti-interleukin-2 (IL-2) Ab's, or recombinant IFN-γ or recombinant IL-2 showed a dramatic increase in susceptibility. Thus, the Th1-type immune response plays a fundamental role in protection against Taenia crassiceps, whereas Th2 does nothing, or may favour parasite establishment (Terrazas et al. 1999).
Together, the above findings prompt the hypothesis that sex steroids act upon parasite loads: oestradiol increases and testosterone limits parasite loads by mechanisms that possibly involve both the immune system of the host and the parasites reproductive system.
The simplest hypothesis to connect the immune response with the females' greater parasite load is to propose that oestradiol directly favours a parasite-permissive Th2 immune response, which in turn down-regulates a parasite-hindering Th1 response. Thus, parasites grow immunologically undisturbed in a female endocrinological environment. The first premise is in keeping with the general notion that females produce more antibodies than males (Ahmed, Talal and Christadoss, 1987; Roberts et al. 2001) and the second refers to Th1/Th2 mutual downregulation (Mosmann and Coffman, 1989).
However, the numbers and types of lymphoid cells trafficking inside the infected peritoneal cavity do not show sexual differences in infected mice (Padilla et al. 2001), nor do the levels of circulating specific antibodies (Sciutto et al. 1990) or splenocyte proliferation and cytokine synthesis in response to in vitro antigen stimulation (Terrazas et al. 1998). The sera of infected mice of both sexes reflect a significant shift from Th1 to Th2 immune response during the course of infection. This is characterized by a marked decrease of IL-2 and IFN γ, enhancement of IL-6, IL-10 and IL-4 secretion (Terrazas et al. 1998; Toenjes et al. 1999; Rodríguez-Sosa et al. 2002). The shift starts in the first week of infection, when parasite reproduction rates are low, reaching an equilibrium in favour of Th2 at 4–6 weeks of infection, when parasites reproduce vigorously. However, the Th1/Th2 shift occurrs similarly in both male and female mice.
Thus, a major sex-associated immunological difference in antibodies or cytokines during infection that would account for the greater parasite loads in female mice could not be established.
Literature abounds on the numerous ways that sex steroids can influence immunologically active cells through their nuclear and membrane receptors to oestradiol, progesterone, prolactin, testosterone and other sex hormone metabolites (Arteaga, Chavarria and Morales-Montor, 2002). It is possible that sex steroids act behind the scenes of the most ostensible markers of immunity, enabling and disabling only the most specifically involved in controlling parasite growth. Can the immune system act upon the parasite by way of its effects on the endocrine system?
Parasite loads of infected males reach the thousands during late infection and the relative sexual differences are minimized. Experiments designed to test an ensuing feminization process as the cause of the large paraite loads of chronically infected mice showed that infected male mice progressively became deandrogenized and oestrogenized (Larralde et al. 1995).
This rather startling finding of ‘parasite-induced feminization of the host’ is almost alone in the literature of parasite infections (Phillips and Cannon, 1978), especially in mammals (Lin et al. 1990; Isseroff et al. 1989) and has, inexplicably, attracted little attention.
Feminization of chronically infected male mice logically follows from the IL-6's known capacity to induce the expression of P-450 aromatase (Reed et al. 1993). This enzyme's overexpression in the male host can shunt the metabolic pathway of testosterone towards dihydrotestosterone and switch it to oestradiol and, hence, feminization, TH1 inhibition and parasite replication. Fig. 1 depicts this hypothetical regulation network. Studies of changes in the infected mice mRNA levels for the enzymes involved in normal male steroid metabolism during infection reveals a decrease in the expression of 5α-reductase type II (the enzyme in charge of the conversion from testosterone to DHT) and an increase in the expression of P450-aromatase (responsible for the conversion of testosterone to oestradiol) (Morales-Montor et al. 1999). So, the shunt of testosterone to oestradiol is indeed turned-on in late infections and the metabolic pathway towards DHT is turned-off in chronically infected male mice. Feminization of the infected male has at least one plausible mechanism mediated by the immune system via Th2-dependent IL-6 (Fig. 1).
The suggestion that the immune system is indeed involved in feminization is supported by the finding that newly-irradiated or thymectomized male strain C57/Bl6 mice fail to feminize when chronically infected (Morales-Montor et al. 2001). The role the of IL-6 is further strengthened by the fact that IL-6-/- (KO) infected mice do not develop the feminization process, while the restitution with IL-6 restores feminization. Further involvement of IL-6 is documented by the testes-enhanced expression of the IL-6 gene. IL-6 has been shown to activate aromatase expression in the testes of cysticercotic mice and to induce active aromatization from androgens to oestrogens (Morales-Montor et al. 2001; Morales-Montor et al. 2002a,b,c). The increased serum levels of follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) (the natural activator of aromatase expression, the secretion of which is also influenced by IL-6) detected in chronically infected mice, supports the notion that FSH interaction with IL-6 in the testes may cooperate in the induction of the feminization process (Morales-Montor et al. 2001).
Interleukin-6 and macrophage migration inhibitory factor (MIF) gene knockout (KO) mice of both sexes show that both male and female (IL6-/- and MIF-/-) mice harbour similar numbers of parasites, with no changes in sex-hormone levels. However, the parental wild-type strains show the sex-associated differences in parasite loads, as well as the feminization of chronically infected male mice (Morales-Montor et al. 2002c). These results suggest that, besides IL-6, the MIF gene also plays a role in sex-associated differences of parasite loads in murine T. crassiceps cysticercosis.
A significant consequence of feminization in chronic infection is that innate sex-associated differences in immunity and/or susceptibility may be concealed by the turning-on of aromatase in the male gonads as a response to infection. Distinct immunological differences between sexes would only be apparent if feminization of the infected male was prevented by blocking aromatase.
The possibility of immune concealment of sexual dimorphism was put to test by the administration of Fadrozole (a P450-aromatase inhibitor and hence suppressor of the production of 17β-oestradiol) to male mice before experimental infection (Morales-Montor et al. 2002b). Fadrozole treatment prevents oestrogenization and deandrogenization; it induces a 70% reduction in parasite loads and increases the splenocyte response to parasite antigens in relation to untreated feminized male mice. Interleukin-6 (IL-6) serum levels and its production by splenocytes are significantly augmented, together with an increase in its expression in the testes of untreated infected male mice. Fadrozole treatment returns these levels to baseline values (Morales-Montor et al. 2002b), implying that feminization does conceal the males more aggressive immunological control of the cysticercus.
Thus, IL-6 is a key molecule of the immune system that connects with the endocrine system through P450-ase, and it oestrogenizes and deandrogenizes the male hosts tending to equilize the parasite intensities and the immune profiles of infected male and female mice late in infection.
The question as to whether oestrogenization and deandrogenization affect the immunologically prominent thymus and spleen has been studied by mRNA expression patterns of c-fos and c-jun, two estradiol-regulated genes, as well as those of the p53 and bcl2 genes in the testes, spleen, and thymus of infected males. It was found that c-fos was significantly increased in all organs, c-jun was increased only in the thymus, p53 mRNA was markedly reduced in all tissues, and bcl2 was abolished only in the thymus (Morales-Montor et al. 1998). Thymic cell analysis performed by flow cytometry showed a reduction in the content of the CD3+, CD4+, and CD8+ subpopulations in the infected male mice. This finding suggests that the increase in oestradiol levels of the host could change the expression pattern of several genes that participate in the regulation of apoptosis in the thymus of male mice during chronic infection with T. crassiceps cysticerci, and that oestrogens may inhibit the cellular immune response to the parasite (Morales-Montor et al. 1998).
In an effort to identify the sex steroids involved in this gene scenario, the effects of testosterone, dihydrotestosterone, and 17β-estradiol in castrated mice of both sexes infected with Taenia crassiceps cysticerci were studied. Castration and treatment with either testosterone or dihydrotestosterone before infection markedly decreases parasite loads in both genders, while the treatment with 17β-oestradiol increases it in both genders. The specific splenocyte cell proliferation and IL-2 and IFN-γ production are depressed in infected-castrated mice of both genders, while treatment with testosterone or dihydrotestosterone produces significant cell proliferation recovery and enhanced production of IL-2 and IFN-γ. The opposite effect of the same sex steroids is found in the humoral response machinery: it is unaffected by testosterone or dihydrotestosterone restitution, while the treatment with oestradiol of both genders augmented the levels of anti-cysticercus IgG, and of IL-6 and IL-10 production. These results are congruent with the idea that androgens mediate immune functions which limit the cysticercus load, possibly through the stimulation of specific cellular immunity of the host (Morales-Montor et al. 2002a,b) (Fig. 2).
Sex steroids can regulate parasite loads through their reciprocal interaction with immune mechanisms but, in addition, they can act directly upon the cysticercus reproductive system (Fig. 2). Oestradiol, and progesterone to a lesser extent, when added to in vitro cultures of T. crassiceps ORF strain, stimulate the parasite's production of buds, their DNA synthesis and [3 H]thymidine uptake, while testosterone and DHT are slightly inhibitory and even exert a pathogenic effect on the parasites (Escobedo et al. 2005). The possible molecular mechanisms by which sex-steroids affect T. crassiceps reproduction imply the presence in the parasite of hormone receptors, a totally unknown issue in cestodes. RT-PCR, and sequencing the specific amplified fragments, have shown the presence of oestradiol receptors (both α and β isoforms) and an androgen receptor, but not of progesterone receptors in the cysticerci of T crassiceps. Moreover, morphological studies of the parasite after sex-steroid treatment demonstrated that the E2 and P4-treated cysticerci are quite mobile, transparent, and surrounded by abundant buds. In contrast, T4 and DHT-treated cysticerci are smaller than the E2 or P4-treated or than untreated cysticerci, and undergo progressive internal disorganization and develop opaque, whitish masses in their teguments, as well as showing progressive loss of motility. Furthermore, not only in vitro treatment of cysticerci affected their survival, but also pre-treatment of T. crassiceps with sex-steroids prior to their inoculation in male or female recipient mice had an effect on their infectivity: oestrogens promoted and androgens inhibited their infectivity. In contrast, prior exposure of parasites to T4 and DHT significantly decreased the expected parasite load in male and female hosts (Escobedo et al. 2005). These last results are the first demonstration that sex steroids of the host may act directly upon parasite reproduction by binding to classic and specific sex-steroid receptors on the parasite and stimulating their natural functions of controlling infectivity, differentiation, reproduction and apoptosis (Escobedo et al. 2005).
Furthermore, it has been shown that T. crassiceps cysticerci are able to metabolize sex-steroid precursors, and thus the parasites can make their own sex-steroids and are possibly sensitive to the host's regulators of hormonal expression (Gómez et al. 2000).
The changes in hormonal host environment in male mice induced by T. crassiceps infection also affect other physiological aspects of the host, such as sexual (Morales et al. 1996), aggresive (Gourbal, Lacroix and Gabrion, 2002) and territorial behaviours (Gourbal et al. 2001). Male mice infected with T. crassiceps show remarkable changes in sexual behaviour: mounting, intromission, and ejaculation responses markedly decline as infection progresses. These sexual changes are characterized by a complete loss of the ejaculation response early at infection (6 weeks), followed by a gradual decrease in the number of mounts and intromissions, and their latencies were increased, until none of the parasitized mice showed any sexual response toward female mice (Morales et al. 1996). Moreover, changes in the sexual behaviour of infected male mice were associated with the serum levels of their sex-steroids, and testosterone or dihydrotestosterone restitution completely restored their normal sexual behaviour (Morales et al. 1996). Furthermore, experimental infection with T. crassiceps cysticerci disrupted the dominant-subordinate status (Gourbal et al. 2002). In infected male mice strong perturbations in territorial behaviour and aggressiveness are found. Infected dominant male mice do not show a significant reversal of dominance order compared to uninfected mice, and during the confrontation between naive infected and healthy mice, infected animals more often assume a subordinate status than healthy mice. The effects of infection by T. crassiceps were more likely to prevent adult male mice from becoming behaviourally dominant than to reverse existing dominance relationships (Gourbal et al. 2001, 2002).
Since c-fos is a key estradiol-regulated transcription factor gene involved in the regulation of sexual behaviour, it is possible that it changes its expression in the central nervous system (CNS) of infected male mice. Indeed c-fos expression showed significant oscillations with time of infection and to different magnitudes in hypothalamus, brain cortex and preoptic area but not in other areas of the brain or in several other organs of the host (Morales-Montor et al. 2004b). Significant changes in c-fos expression in the CNS during infection indicate that the brain senses the infection episode and may become involved in the ensuing behavioural changes of the infected mice. Through its extensive network of connections, the CNS may well extend the effects of infection to other physiological systems under its influence.
Whether changes in the CNS are beneficial or not to the host or parasite remains speculative (Klein, 2000). One could argue that feminization of the male intermediate hosts favours the parasite by allowing reproduction in otherwise restrictive male mice, but equally arguable would be to consider feminization of the male host as deleterious to the parasite's completion of its cycle by reducing the male's exposure to its predators, the definitive hosts. Other similar mutually conflicting statements may be elaborated with the above premises, the true ones remain to be identified and could perhaps vary in each different host-parasite relationship.
We have documented here that a complex interactive network involving the immune, endocrine and nervous systems of the mouse, as well as the reproductive system of the cysticerci, is in control of the parasite load of each infected mouse. If such a complex management of parasite loads (as that shown here between mice and cysticerci) extends to other parasite diseases of mammals (as current research seems to indicate in a number of infections) their means of exploration, understanding and forms of control must be reviewed and approached with designs matching in complexity and plasticity that of the physiology of infections.
Host and parasite sex-associated biases may be combined to favour their evolution towards a mutually acceptable relationship. Moreover, the changes in behaviour observed during cysticercosis, should not be regarded as simple biological curiosities but more as strong evidence of the plasticity of the host phenotype in response to infection by parasitic helminths. Furthermore, by changing the reproductive, aggressive and dominant capacity of the host, parasites generate novel questions regarding the evolution of host-parasite relationships in ways involving prey/predator interactions, stress, foraging, reproduction, and sexual selection (Zuk and Mc Kean, 1996).
In practical matters, the complexity of the host-parasite relationship suggests that all physiological factors (i.e. sex, age, developmental stage) should be taken into account in the design of vaccines and new drugs. Interventions aimed at the hormonal network appear as a possible new therapeutic approach to control murine cysticercosis in its intermediate host, and perhaps other infections.
Financial support was from Grant no. 40072-Q from Consejo Nacional de Ciencia y Tecnología (CONACYT) de México, and Grant no. IN-208103 from Programa de Apoyo a Proyectos de Investigación e Inovación Tecnológica (PAPIIT) from Dirección General de Asuntos del Personal Académico (DGAPA), U.N.A.M., both to J.M.-M. Isabel Pérez Montfort corrected the English version of the manuscript.