Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-kw2vx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-02-11T14:57:03.294Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

R.A. DANNER and J. WINTERTON (eds). The IALL International Handbook of Legal Information Management. Farnham: Ashgate Publishing, 2011. ISBN: 9780754674771. 392 pp.

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 March 2012

Katherine Jackson
Affiliation:
Legal Research Librarian, Bodleian Law Library
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Type
Book Reviews
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s) 2012. Published by British and Irish Association of Law Librarians

The International Handbook of Legal Information Management provides a fascinating and detailed discussion of the issues surrounding not only those directly involved with legal information with an international flavour, but all legal information professionals. The book is written by a range of experienced and very knowledgeable authors and pulls together the different strands very well.

The book has a mixture of chapters about international law librarianship itself, the nature of legal information, and where these both fit into the wider legal environment. There are some common themes running through the book, mainly the impact of globalisation and the digital dissemination of legal information. The chapters vary from information literacy to comparative law, legal practice and legal publishing to collection building in both electronic and print. One great feature of the book is that each chapter references a large number of studies and provides any interested party with a list of further reading.

The book is nicely set up by a very good discussion in chapter 1 on the definition of international law librarianship which introduces the themes mentioned above. It is not possible to talk about each chapter in the book, but it is possible to touch in more detail on some chapters that are particularly interesting, like the chapter on the ‘Free Access to Law movement’. This chapter is especially important in the international context of what is happening in different jurisdictions and this coupled with the chapter on ‘Digitising the World's Laws’ gives an idea of the impact of globalisation and information technology and the way it has changed information provision. The snapshot of law librarianship in a range of different countries in chapter 8 was enlightening and it was almost a shame to stop at the six. The countries chosen feature a nice mixture of experiences and was not too heavily skewed towards the more traditional jurisdictions. The chapter on ‘Information Literacy’ was also good in the way it highlights the changing nature of legal resources, the impact this has had on how lawyers, academics, and students research and how librarians can make an impact in training legal research skills within this new environment.

One criticism of the book is that, given the distinct focus of each of the chapters, it does not flow as well as it might. This is probably down to the different authors with different writing styles, as well as having quite a broad range of subjects and perspectives. This means that for the newcomer it can seem a little overwhelming and for those more experienced a little too disjointed to read as a complete work. There was also some overlap with some of the chapters but this is to be expected because of the nature of the subject. It would not be something to be read cover-to-cover as a complete handbook or practical guide as such, but it does allow for the reader to dip in and discover the different aspects as suits their purpose and interest. This seems to be the intention of the book as evidenced by Richard Susskind in the foreword where he says, “It will provide law librarians not with a manual of best practice for the administration of law libraries…” but “…a definitive guide to the central issues of policy and strategy that are of direct concern to the progressive law librarian (and the legal profession) of tomorrow”.

So who would benefit from reading the book? The books states in the preface that “It provides resources, analysis and considered studies both for seasoned international law librarians, those about to enter the field, and others interested in the evolution of legal information in the twenty-first century” which is casting the net quite wide. There are some chapters that provide very useful historical background to the subject for example the first chapter and the two chapters on building a collection. However with other chapters there is a presumption of a certain amount of knowledge that may be a little bit off putting to somebody new. For most chapters there are ample references to further reading that would aid a newcomer to discover a fuller picture and so that is not of itself a reason to dismiss.

There is also a very strong focus on academic law librarianship and collections management in some of the chapters, which is not surprising given that a large number of the authors are in an academic role. Because of this some of the points may be lost or not relevant to those in the commercial sector. However chapter 5 focuses specifically on the ‘Global Legal Practice’ and as the book deals with very broad themes that affect all sectors it is not something that should put off those in law firms in investing in a copy. The evidence provided in the book in the form of robust studies and statistics, as well as the case studies, can be used to further development and discussion of information provision in both academic and commercial settings alike.

Overall it is a good read and something that should be bought, not as a definitive guide to help in the practical day to day running of an information service, but of a collection of interesting and engaging essays that can promote ideas and discussions about international law librarianship and its future role.