Hostname: page-component-745bb68f8f-grxwn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-02-11T20:08:08.964Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The Democratic Republic of Congo: economic dimensions of war and peace by Michael Nest, with François Grignon and Emizet F. Kisangani New York: International Peace Academy, 2006. Pp. 162. US$15.95 (pbk.).

Review products

The Democratic Republic of Congo: economic dimensions of war and peace by Michael Nest, with François Grignon and Emizet F. Kisangani New York: International Peace Academy, 2006. Pp. 162. US$15.95 (pbk.).

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  16 July 2007

DENIS M. TULL
Affiliation:
German Institute for International and Security Affairs
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Type
Book Review
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2007

Emanating from a project of the International Peace Academy, the book investigates a subject which has caught the limelight of research on contemporary conflicts: the economic dimensions of war (and peace). Contrary to what the title may insinuate, readers should not expect an in-depth analysis that refers to the greed vs. grievance debate with particular respect to the conflict in the DRC. The core of the book is dedicated to the question of whether and how attempts to solve the conflict have addressed economic agendas of the parties to the conflict. To this extent, international involvement for a lasting peace in the DRC emerges as the central topic of the book.

In addition to the introduction and the conclusion, which draw a number of interesting lessons from the case of the DRC, the small volume consists of four chapters. Chapter 2 by Michael Nest provides a concise and useful overview of the various wars (local, national, regional) which have often been lumped together as constituting one single conflict. Also authored by Nest, chapter 3, ‘The Political Economy of the Congo War’, examines the interests of the various parties to the conflict, including Congolese actors, neighbouring countries and multinational firms, paying particular attention to the evolution of interests that underpinned the peculiar dynamics of the war over time. Although mainly based on well-known material, Nest offers a carefully balanced assessment that makes clear that ‘while economic agendas became a prominent part of the conflict, they emerged as a function of war’ (p. 31). To the degree that the ‘cost imperative of waging war and the presence of conditions that created many opportunities for profit making’ (p. 54) gave rise to economic agendas, these added to and at times overshadowed the initial political and security interests of the actors involved.

The following contribution by François Grignon, a former director of the Central Africa project of the International Crisis Group and now serving with MONUC, analyses to what extent economic agendas have been incorporated into the peace processes associated with the Congo War. By meticulously tracing the peace negotiations from the Lusaka ceasefire agreement of 1999 to the Pretoria accord of 2002 and beyond, Grignon advances the compelling argument that all sides to the conflict played a ‘fool's game’ with regard to the importance of addressing economic agendas for finding a lasting solution to the conflict. Not only did all parties deny that deeply entrenched economic interests had become part and parcel of the conflict. Even after the issue had hit the international spotlight, all the actors concerned literally pledged innocence: the Congolese actors by pretending that they would henceforth ‘support radical reforms in the management of the DRC's state and economy’, which they had and arguably still have no intention of putting into practice; the international community, notably the Western members of the UN Security Council, by indulging in hypocrisy about the economic interests that their multinational companies were pursuing in the DRC. As a result of half solutions, and because no side was serious about implementation, as well as the neglect of local conflicts and spoilers in Eastern Congo, Grignon concludes that peace in the DRC is a ‘negative peace – actually, no peace at all in much of Eastern DRC – that leaves most grievances and structural opportunities for economic predation intact’ (p. 92).

The yawning discrepancies between economic and political attempts at the macro-level to promote peace and the realities on the ground are further elaborated by Emizet Kisangani in his chapter on the ‘Legacies of the War Economy’. Like nearly all the contributions in the volume, he emphasises the historical continuities of predatory mechanisms that have characterised colonial and postcolonial rule in the Congo, some of which have been partially transformed during the war. Given the shortcomings of international efforts to address the causes and consequences of conflict, he remains deeply sceptical about the prospects of the various regulatory frameworks that aim at restructuring Congo's war economy to an economy of peace. This is mainly because the entitlements (property rights in general, access to land in particular, citizenship etc.) that would provide ordinary Congolese with incentives to support a new political and economic order in the DRC are barely taken into account by the kind of macro-level policies advocated by the international community. In summary, Economic Dimensions of War and Peace makes a valuable contribution to our understanding of the political and economic dynamics in the DRC that will almost certainly remain pertinent after the holding of the post-transition elections in late 2006. In that regard, this reviewer's impression that the manuscript has taken some time to be published (as is apparent from a lack of reference to more recent events in the Congo) seems to be a minor deficit.