Introduction
In order to properly honour the important work of surgical instrument design that has culminated in safe tonsillectomy technique, we need to consider the question of where we would otherwise be were these instruments never invented for use. Celsus (25BC–AD50), a Roman aristocrat who has described the tonsillectomy in his time, may have the answer:
They ought to be disengaged all round by the finger and removed. If they are not separated by this method, it is necessary to take them up with a blunt hook and separate them with a scalpel; then to wash them with vinegar and anoint the wound with a styptic application.Reference McNeill1
The eponymous contents of the tonsillectomy tray offer an insight into a group of surgeon inventors that represents an intriguing and, at times, surprising surgical history of endeavour, innovation and sacrifice towards the betterment of surgical procedures. This fact ought to be honoured by all who benefit from their contributions. What follows is a short biography of each surgeon inventor.
Tonsillectomy tray instruments
The contents of the standard tonsillectomy tray are demonstrated in Figure 1, and a summary of the tonsillectomy tray instrument inventors is provided in Table I.
Fig. 1 The tonsillectomy tray instruments.
Table I Summary of the tonsillectomy tray instrument inventors
Toothed and non-toothed Waugh forceps
Mr Alexander Waugh (1840–1906) was known as ‘The Brute’ because of his habit of beating his dog and bullying those close to him. Perhaps the kindest notation regarding his lifetime contributions was his invention of ‘Waugh's Long Fine Dissecting Forceps’.2
Mr Waugh is the fount of one of the most celebrated literary families in England. His grandson was the great Evelyn Waugh (1903–1966) acclaimed as one of the finest novelists of the English language, and author of ‘Brideshead Revisited’. However, in a recent family autobiography, surviving relative Alexander Waugh Jr describes Alexander Waugh Sr as the fount also for a talent for sadism.2, 3 The latter's great, great grandson Bron is said to have ‘made so many enemies, that his obituary in The Guardian newspaper was illustrated with a drawing of his corpse being washed down a lavatory pan’.2
Straight Birkett forceps
Mr John Birkett (1815–1904) was an English surgeon who specialised in breast disease, and was an early advocate of histology.Reference John Birkett4
He was an only child, and started as an apprentice to Bransby Cooper, surgeon at Guy's Hospital, London, at the age of 16 years. He commenced his medical studies the following year, obtaining his Fellowship of the Royal College of Surgeons qualification in 1844.Reference John Birkett4
For his dissertation on ‘Diseases of the Breast and their Treatment’, he was awarded the Jacksonian Prize by the Royal College of Surgeons in 1848. He maintained a close relationship with the Royal College of Surgeons; he was a council member from 1867, Hunterian Professor of Pathology and Surgery, vice president and finally, president of the Royal College of Surgeons in 1877.Reference John Birkett4
With regard to his personal life, Birkett married Lucy Matilda in 1845 and they went on to have a family of seven sons (two of which became distinguished rugby players) and three daughters.Reference John Birkett4
Fraser–Kelly artery forceps
Professor Howard Atwood Kelly (1858–1943) (Figure 2) was an American gynaecologist. He was known to many as one of the ‘Big Four’: he was one of the four founding professors at the John Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore (in the company of Osler, Halsted and Welch).5
Fig. 2 Professor Howard Atwood Kelly (1858–1943). Reproduced with permission of the University of Pennsylvania Archives.6
Born in New Jersey to a prosperous sugar broker, Kelly was educated at the University of Pennsylvania. He graduated with a Bachelor of Arts degree in 1877 and qualified as a Doctor of Medicine in 1882.Reference Kelly6 He spent his early medical life in Philadelphia, before being invited by William Osler, the chairmen of medicine of the newly founded John Hopkins University in Baltimore, to take up the position of Professor of Gynaecology and Obstetrics in 1889 (at the age of 31 years). It was in this year that Kelly married Laetitia Bredow, with whom he had nine children.5–Reference Roberts7
Kelly's contributions included new surgical approaches to women's diseases, development of the cystoscope, and pioneering cocaine as a local anaesthetic and radium to treat cancer.5–Reference Roberts7 He founded the Kelly clinic, which was once one of the country's leading centres for gynaecological radiation therapy.Reference Kelly6 Kelly was president of the Southern Surgical and Gynecological Society (1907), president of the American Gynecological Society (1912) and a founding member of the American College of Surgeons (1913). He published over 500 scholarly pieces in his field of expertise, as well as in medical biography, botany and the natural sciences.5–Reference Roberts7 His name has also taken a number of other eponymous forms: Kelly's sign, the Kelly speculum and the Kelly stitch.Reference Kelly8
Kelly, the man, has been recalled as being a reptile collector and fundamentalist evangelical Christian.5–Reference Roberts7 These characteristics drew him to the attention of Baltimore columnist HL Mencken, who described him at the age of 63 years as follows:
Before cock-crow in the morning, he has got out of bed, held a song and praise service, read two or three chapters in his Greek Old Testament, sung a couple of hymns, cut off six or eight legs, pulled out a pint of tonsils and eyeballs, relieved a dozen patients of their appendices, filled the gall-stone keg in the corner, pronounced the benediction, washed up, filled his pockets with tracts, got into a high-speed automobile with the Rev. W. W. Davis and started off at 50 miles an hour to raid a gambling house and close the red light district…Reference Roberts7
Original source: Mencken HL (under pseudonym). Mirrors of Maryland, September 30, 1921.
Negus artery forceps and Negus knot pusher
Sir Victor Ewings Negus (1887–1974) (Figure 3) was, for many years, consultant surgeon at the ENT department at King's College Hospital, London.Reference Negus, Fish and Campbell9–Reference Negus11
Fig. 3 Sir Victor Ewings Negus (1887–1974). Copyright The Royal College of Surgeons England. Reproduced with permission.10
After serving with the Royal Army Medical Corps in France in 1914, Negus became a Fellow of the Royal College of Surgeons, in 1921. He rose to staff status as an ENT surgeon after undertaking important original research in the field of comparative anatomy of the larynx. This work was awarded the Master of Surgery gold medal and, later, the John Hunter medal, and culminated in the publication ‘The Mechanisms of the Larynx’ in 1929. It was also in 1929 that Negus married his wife, Gladys (Eve) Rennie, who would assist her husband as a medical illustrator for several of his books. Victor and Eve went on to have two sons.Reference Negus, Fish and Campbell9–Reference Negus11
Negus's credits included the development of new surgical techniques and the improvement of panendoscopy instrumentation.Reference Negus11 He published a number of textbooks, the most notable of which is ‘Disease of the Nose and Throat’, written in collaboration with St Clair Thomson, which stood for many years as the authoritative textbook on the subject. Negus also made a great contribution to his profession outside of his clinical work. He was the curator of the Ferens Institute of the Middlesex Hospital Medical School, served the Royal College of Surgeons as a representative of otolaryngology on the council between 1947 and 1952, and played a central role in founding the final examination in otolaryngology.
Negus received numerous highly esteemed awards and was the honorary member of multiple otolaryngology societies around the world. He was president of the 4th International Congress of Otolaryngology in London, president of the Thoracic Society, president of the laryngology sector of the Royal Society of Medicine and president of the British Association of Otolaryngologists, the latter of which proved to be fundamental in ensuring that otolaryngology was accepted as a major specialty in the National Health Service.Reference Bateman10, Reference Negus11
As a man, Negus was described in his obituary, published in The Lancet in 1974, as having a very full social life:
He played tennis regularly until he was 70, and then concentrated on golf, which had always been his regular winter game. He was a great competitor and always very hard to beat.Reference Negus11
Yankauer suction tip
Dr Sidney Yankauer (1872–1932) (Figure 4) was an American ENT surgeon, who was based at New York's Mount Sinai Hospital for much of his career.12, Reference Smith and Padfield13
Fig. 4 Dr Sidney Yankauer (1872–1932). Copyright [1932, John wiley & Sons Inc.]. This material is reproduced with permission of John Wiley & Sons, Inc.12
Yankauer was born the son of German Jewish immigrants from Bavaria; he was one of six children. He graduated from the City College of New York in 1890, the first free public institution for higher education in the USA. He went on to study at the College of Physicians and Surgeons in New York (later part of Columbia University), completing his medical degree in 1893. He undertook his internship at Mount Sinai Hospital, where he went on to specialise in ENT surgery and be appointed Attending Laryngologist in 1917. Yankauer served in the World War I effort as a major in the US Army Base Hospital based in Vauclair, which treated some 9000 casualties.Reference Smith and Padfield13
By this time, Yankauer had married Grace Greenwood Prior; she had qualified from the Women's Medical Dispensary in New York and would too specialise in ENT.Reference Smith and Padfield13 However, a tragic fall ended her life at the age of 40 years. Yankauer went on to marry Margaret Kearns and they had his only daughter together.Reference Smith and Padfield13
Dr Yankauer contributed more than 100 papers to the surgical literature, with topics ranging from leeches in the trachea, to ground-breaking bronchoscopic treatment of lung abscesses and the application of radium to carcinoma of the oesophagus.Reference Smith and Padfield13 The Yankauer sucker, which was designed to keep the surgical field clear during tonsillectomy, was developed around 1907. He also developed the Yankauer ether and chloroform mask (circa 1904), and the Yankauer suction and pressure anaesthesia pump (circa 1920). He was an active member of many learned societies.Reference Smith and Padfield13
Draffin bipods
The story of Mr David Alexander Draffin (1917–1965) (Figure 5) was recently retold by Bennett and Young, in 1992.Reference Bennett and Young14
Fig. 5 David Alexander Draffin (1917–1965). Reproduced with permission.14
Draffin was born in Ballybay, Ireland in 1917. He studied medicine at Queen's University, where his early sporting and athletic prowess was legendary. At the tender age of 22 years, newly qualified, Draffin volunteered himself for the army and served as a regimental medical officer in the British Expeditionary Force (the youngest person to do so). In this role, Mr Draffin cheated death, which was the fate of 26 members of his regiment, in the massacre at Le Paradis, although he did not escape capture.Reference Bennett and Young14
Mr Draffin was a defiant captive; he saved the lives of 90 prisoners of war, only to be wounded and recaptured. He served six terms in solitary confinement because of his repeated escape attempts. Finally, he escaped successfully, by swimming across the Elbe.Reference Bennett and Young14
As a consequence of his wartime experiences, Mr Draffin is said to have found it difficult to adjust to post-war normalcy. His Fellowship of the Royal College of Surgeons qualification was never finished.Reference Bennett and Young14 He occupied the interim period between his return from war and demise with property dealings and experiences in ENT surgery, which provided enough recompense to support the purchase of two Rolls Royce cars. However, 6 days after being called to a final hearing with the General Medical Council for a drink driving charge (which he failed to attend citing he was ‘too busy reading about the fall of the Roman Empire’), Mr Draffin was found dead in his apartment from a myocardial infarct.Reference Bennett and Young14
Gwynne-Evans tonsil dissector
Mr Eric ‘Taffy’ Gwynne-Evans (1904–1989) first reported on his new tonsil dissector in The Lancet in 1935 (Figure 6), when he was 31 years old.Reference Gwynne-Evans15 He was a consultant ENT surgeon at St George's Hospital, having previously worked at the Miller General Hospital and in the Victoria Hospital, London.
Fig. 6 Gwynne-Evans’ tonsils dissector publication. Reprinted from The Lancer, 226, Gwynne-Evans E, A new tonsil dissector, 556., Copyright (1935), with permission from Elsevier.15
Gwynne-Evans would be remembered for his years of work in the field of speech and linguistics, for research undertaken analysing the relationships between orofacial structures, muscle behaviour and orthodontic patterns. The culmination of his research work was several scientific papers, and an appointment as honorary fellow of the College of Speech Therapists.16
Gwynne-Evans was described as being a conservative surgeon and a talented cinematographer. This led to his assisting Sir Terence Cawthorne in the illustration of the technique of labyrinthectomy at the 4th International Congress of Otolaryngology in 1949.16 He married Betty McDonald King in 1932 and was survived by a son and daughter.
Mollison pillar retractor
Mr William Mayhew Mollison (1878–1967) was a British ENT surgeon at Guy's Hospital.17 He also spent time assisting Walter Howarth in his editorship of The Journal of Laryngology & Otology.18
He was born in Cambridge in 1878, the son of William Loudon Mollison, the latter of whom had risen from humble beginnings to become a leading mathematician and master of Clare College, Cambridge.17 Mollison Jr married Beatrice Marjory Walker in 1908, with whom he shared six children. One of his children was Professor Patrick Mollison, a pioneer in blood transfusion in World War II, who performed the first exchange transfusion on a British newborn with blood poisoning from rhesus incompatibility.Reference Professor Patrick19
Luc's forceps
Dr Henri Luc (1855–1925) is considered the father of French otorhinology.Reference Luc20 His practice examined the relationship between inflammation of the nose and ear, and was devoted to the treatment of frontal and maxillary sinus disease. He gave the first description of his operation on the maxillary sinus in 1897 (independently described by the American physician, George Walter Caldwell).Reference Luc20
Dr Luc was born in Saint-Omer in 1855. He was a successful student at Lille, and was appointed prosector at the age of 20 years. He undertook medical studies in Paris, and completed his doctorate in 1884. His specialisation in otolaryngology evolved in Vienna, under the traineeship of Adam Politzer (the otology pioneer) and Leopold von Schrotter.Reference Luc20
Denis Browne forceps
Whichever of his various talents he was exploiting – playing tennis at Wimbledon, lecturing students at home or pundits abroad, coping with a baby's cleft lip or club foot – he gave everything he had, with towering energy.21
Sir Denis John Wolko Browne (1892–1967) (Figure 7) was an Australian paediatric surgeon and a founder of the British Association of Paediatric Surgeons.Reference Dunn22, Reference Browne23
Fig. 7 Sir Denis John Wolko Browne (1892–1967). Reproduced from [Sir Denis Browne (1892–1967) and congenital deformities of mechanical origin, Dunn PM, 90, F88–91, 2005] with permission from BMJ Publishing Group Ltd.22
He was born in Toorak, Melbourne to his native-born parents of high social standing. He was educated privately and completed his medical studies at The University of Sydney, gaining his Bachelor of Medicine degree in 1914.
Perhaps his sporting prowess was heralded by his towering frame; he was given the Aboriginal name ‘Wolko’ meaning ‘big man’ at birth as he was ‘extra-long’. He won ‘Blue’ awards (for competition at the highest level) in shooting and tennis, and excelled at billiards, golf and horsemanship.Reference Browne23
At the age of 23 years, Browne was appointed captain in the Australian Army Medical Corps as part of the Australian Imperial Force. His assignments included regimental medical officer with the 13th Light Horse Brigade at Gallipoli, 12th Field Ambulance in France and 3rd Australian Auxillary Hospital in England (as a major).Reference Browne23
It was in England where Browne's surgical ability became noticed, and he was permitted leave to gain experience under the orthopaedic surgeon Sir Robert Jones at the Royal Southern Hospital in Liverpool. He later resigned from the Australian Imperial Force to work in Middlesex and London hospitals.Reference Browne23
In 1922, Browne completed his Fellowship of the Royal College of Surgeons qualification and took up employment as resident medical superintendent at The Hospital for Sick Children, Great Ormond Street, London.Reference Browne23 In 1927, he married the Australian novelist Helen de Guerry Simpson. Helen died in 1940 leaving their one daughter, Clemence. Browne later married Lady Moyra Ponsonby, a trained nurse.Reference Browne23
In 1928, Browne rose to the role of consultant surgeon at Great Ormond Street where his original thinking flourished. Here, he developed a technique for cleft palate and hare lip repair, recommended ‘controlled movement’ for treating talipes and congenital hip dislocation, and better defined imperforate anus and undescended testes.Reference Browne23 He was regarded as a pioneer of neonatal surgery, and advocated specialised skills, techniques and instruments for operating on the young.
Browne travelled widely to lecture, and was awarded multiple honorary memberships. He was awarded the Hunter professorship four times. Among his many accolades, Browne was appointed as Knight Commander of the Royal Victorian Order by Queen Elizabeth II and the Légion d'honneur (Legion of Honour) by the French government. He was made an honorary fellow of the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons in 1965, and in 1967 he served as president of the International College of Surgeons.Reference Browne23
Boyle–Davis mouth gag
Dr Henry Edmund Gaskin Boyle OBE (1875–1941) was a pioneer anaesthetist, credited with the early development of anaesthetic machines.Reference Wilkinson and Boyle24, Reference Boyle25
He was born in Barbados, before moving to England to complete his medical qualification. In 1901, he completed the Membership of the Royal College of Surgeons Licentiate of the Royal College of Physicians (‘MRCS LRCP’) qualification at St Bartholomew's Hospital, where he was appointed as junior anaesthetist, and subsequently as a visiting consultant.Reference Wilkinson and Boyle24, Reference Boyle25
During the World War I effort, Boyle employed his nitrous oxide, oxygen and ether anaesthetic method in his work for the Royal Army Medical Corps in London. He was awarded the Officer of the Order of the British Empire title for his work.Reference Wilkinson and Boyle24, Reference Boyle25
Dr Boyle's innovation led to the development of his own continuous-flow machine. His left-handedness led to machines the world over being left-handed until being revised in the 1950s.Reference Wilkinson and Boyle24, Reference Boyle25 Dr Boyle served as president in the anaesthetics section of the Royal Society of Medicine (1923), was a founding member of the Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland, and was an examiner for the Diploma of Anaesthesia.Reference Wilkinson and Boyle24, Reference Boyle25
In 2000, Boyle was honoured at St Bartholomew's Hospital, which renamed their department the ‘Boyle Department of Anaesthesia’.Reference Wilkinson and Boyle24, Reference Boyle25
Conclusion
In an endeavour to uncover the hidden historical context of our tonsillectomy tray, what is revealed is an esteemed and highly diverse group of surgeon inventors. Their stories span two centuries of medicine, featuring England, the USA, France and Australia, and joining together the specialties of general surgery, otolaryngology, gynaecology, paediatric surgery and anaesthetics. It is hoped that the next time the reader selects an eponymous instrument from their own instrument tray, they may look upon it with heightened appreciation and curiosity of the story behind it.