Introduction
Cystic echinococcosis (CE) caused by Echinococcus granulosus, an ancient zoonotic disease, is considered to be one of the most important parasitic infectious diseases in livestock. The parasite life cycle circulates between carnivores as a definitive host and herbivores as an intermediate host. In addition to the economic losses resulting from the infected organs, an infection of the intermediate host has a negative economic influence on the animal products such as meat, milk and wool. CE is known as an endemic disease in the Mediterranean region, including all countries of the Middle East (Andersen et al., Reference Andersen, Ouhelli and Kashani1997; Sadjjadi, Reference Sadjjadi2006; Rokni, Reference Rokni2009). Hydatid cysts have been reported in sheep, goats, cattle, camels and buffaloes as intermediate hosts in countries of the Middle East such as Iran, Iraq, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and Pakistan (Dailey et al., Reference Dailey, Sweatman and Schacher1966; Hassounah & Behbehani, Reference Hassounah and Behbehani1976; Dajani, Reference Dajani1978; Ghandour & Saleh, Reference Ghandour and Saleh1983; Al-Yaman et al., Reference Al-Yaman, Assaf, Hailat and Abdel-Hafez1985; Abdel-Hafez et al., Reference Abdel-Hafez, Al Yaman and Said1986; Farah, Reference Farah1987; Ghandour, Reference Ghandour1988; Abo-Shehada, Reference Abo-Shehada1993; Molan, Reference Molan1993; Oryan et al., Reference Oryan, Moghaddar and Gaur1994; Kamhawi et al., Reference Kamhawi, Hijjawi, Abu-Ghazaleh and Abbas1995; Rokni, Reference Rokni2009). In the Middle East, an infection rate of 1.5–37.8% has been reported in infected animals (Matossian et al., Reference Matossian, Rickard and Smyth1977; Andersen et al., Reference Andersen, Ouhelli and Kashani1997; Rokni, Reference Rokni2009). In Iran, previous studies from various parts of the country confirm that it is one of the endemic areas for E. granulosus and hydatid cysts in the world (Eslami & Hosseini, Reference Eslami and Hosseini1998; Rokni, Reference Rokni2009). Reported infection rates in Iran have been 3.5–38.3% in cattle, 5.1–74.4% in sheep and 1.7–20% in goats (Eslami & Mohebali, Reference Eslami and Mohebali1988; Eslami & Hosseini, Reference Eslami and Hosseini1998; Rokni, Reference Rokni2009).
According to the report of the Iranian veterinary organization, the population of buffaloes is estimated to be 447,000, of which 435,320 buffaloes are in West Azerbaijan (113,070), East Azerbaijan (89,060), Ardabil (106,750), Gilan (25,850) and Khuzestan (100,590), where the present study was performed.
The aim of the present study was to determine the prevalence, fertility and viability of cysts in the liver and lungs of buffaloes. Furthermore, the role of buffaloes in the epidemiology of CE was also determined.
Materials and methods
The present study was carried out between November 2008 and May 2010 on hydatid cysts isolated from the livers and lungs of naturally infected buffaloes obtained from five abattoirs in Iran: Urmia (West Azerbaijan; 37°53′N and 45°00′E), Tabriz (East Azerbaijan; 38°04′N and 46°18′E), Ardabil (Ardabil; 38°15′N and 48°17′E), Rasht (Gilan; 37°03′N and 49°63′E) and Ahvaz (Khuzestan; 20°31′N and 48°41′E).
Parasitological procedure
Animals were inspected for the presence of hydatid cysts; sex, age and infected organs were recorded separately. The cysts detected in liver and lungs were examined by both observation and palpation. All cysts were aspirated using a needle and samples transferred into a sterile container. The cyst fluid was centrifuged and examined microscopically ( × 40) for the presence of protoscoleces. Cysts containing protoscoleces were considered to be fertile, while the cysts that did not have protoscoleces, or suppurative and calcified cysts, were considered as unfertile cysts. The viability of the protoscoleces was assessed by motility of flame cells or by using 0.1% aqueous eosin staining, examined under a light microscope (Smyth & Barrett, Reference Smyth and Barrett1980).
Data analysis
Statistical tests were performed using SPSS software (version 16; SPSS, Inc., Chicago, Illinois, USA). Regression analysis testing was applied to determine the association of age and infection rate. A χ2 test was performed to compare the difference between specific organ infection and infection rate and also between sex and infection rate.
Results
The prevalence, fertility and viability of hydatid cysts in buffaloes were determined and the maximum and minimum prevalence rates were found in Khuzestan (9.9%) and in Ardabil (8%), respectively; and there were no significant differences between the rates of infection (table 1). The fertility rate of hydatid cysts in infected animals was 7.3% and the viability rate of fertile cysts was 78.75%. The distribution of hydatid cysts in different organs is shown in table 2. Hydatid cysts were more prevalent in the lungs than in the liver in all the areas examined (P < 0.001).
Comparison between sexes: *, P < 0.05; **, P < 0.01; ***, P < 0.001.
*** Comparison between liver and lungs (P < 0.001).
Frequencies and prevalence of hydatid cysts in buffaloes of different age ranges are shown in table 3. The rate of infection increased with age and there was a positive correlation between age and rate of infection in all provinces (P < 0.05) except East Azerbaijan (table 3), and female buffaloes were more infected than males (P < 0.05) (table 1). The frequencies of hydatid cysts based on sex and age groups in infected buffaloes showed that, of the infected males, 15 (1.4%) were less than 2 years old, 38 (8.9%) were between 2 and 5 years old, 13 (14.3%) were between 5 and 9 years old and 0 (0%) were more than 9 years old. The frequencies of female infected buffaloes were, in the above-mentioned age groups, 2 (0.4%), 18 (3.3%), 108 (14.3%) and 150 (32.9%), respectively. The average number of cysts per infected animal was 3.8 (range 1–24) and their size ranged from 2 to 12 cm.
* Correlation between the age and number of infected hosts (P < 0.05).
Discussion
Hydatidosis is one of the most important medical and veterinary diseases in Iran. The major reservoir hosts for humans are sheep, cattle, goats and buffaloes (Moghaddar et al., Reference Moghaddar, Oryan and Hanife Pour1992; Oryan et al., Reference Oryan, Moghaddar and Gaur1994). The results of the present study are important in providing better understanding of the epidemiology of CE in water buffaloes. There is no complete epidemiological study of hydatidosis in buffaloes except scattered investigations in limited areas in Iran.
Few surveys have been conducted on the prevalence, fertility and viability of hydatid cysts in buffaloes from Iran. Samavatian et al. (Reference Samavatian, Valilou, Lotfi, Yousef Khani and Mirzaei2009) inspected 411 buffaloes at the Ahar abattoir (Arasbaran region, north-western Iran) and found that 31.87% of buffaloes were infected with hydatid cysts. Also, Dalimi et al. (Reference Dalimi, Motamedi, Hosseini, Mohammadian, Malaki, Ghamari and Ghaffari Far2002) inspected 659 buffaloes in Urmia and found that 12.4% of buffaloes were infected. From these animals, 36.6% of infections were detected in the liver, 36.6% in lungs and 26.8% in both organs. In the present study, we found that the fertility rate in liver and lungs was 2.9 and 12%, respectively. It has also been shown that the viability rate of fertile cysts in liver and lungs was 50.0 and 56.7 ± 5.8, respectively. Our results are in agreement with Dalimi et al. (Reference Dalimi, Motamedi, Hosseini, Mohammadian, Malaki, Ghamari and Ghaffari Far2002) with respect to prevalence, fertility rate and age; however, the prevalence of infected lungs in the present study was higher.
Daryani et al. (Reference Daryani, Alaei, Arab, Sharif, Dehghan and Ziaei2007) inspected 243 buffaloes in Ardabil and reported that the rate of infected animals was 11.9%. They showed that the percentage of infected males was 9.3% while the percentage of infected females was also 9.3%. Mehrabani et al. (Reference Mehrabani, Oryan and Sadjjadi1999) inspected 25 buffaloes in Shiraz (southern Iran) and reported a prevalence rate of 4 and 8% in liver and lungs, respectively. Khanmohammadi et al. (Reference Khanmohammadi, Gayem Maghami and Zakaria Zadeh2008) inspected 856 buffaloes (154 males and 702 females) from the Tabriz abattoir and showed that the prevalence rate was 25.84% (22.36% of males and 26.49% of females). They observed 158 (33.83%), 466 (70.28%) and 17 (2.56%) cysts in livers, lungs and kidneys, respectively. The present results are in agreement with this study but the total prevalence in the present study was less than reported by Khanmohammadi et al. (Reference Khanmohammadi, Gayem Maghami and Zakaria Zadeh2008). We found more females infected with CE than males in all the areas studied. Susceptibility of female buffaloes to CE may be due to immunodeficiency and decreased cell-mediated immunity in pregnancy and the lactation period. In addition, animal owners in Iran prefer to slaughter female animals in old age but male animals at a young age. So, another reason for the increased infection rate in female buffaloes could be due to the high slaughter age of female animals. Akhondzade Basti et al. (Reference Akhondzade Basti, Rokni, Hajimohamadi, Athari, Misaghi and Gandomi Narbada2009) inspected 547 buffaloes in Urmia slaughter houses and found 58 (10.6%) infected with hydatid cysts, from which 45 (77.5%), 37 (63.7%) and 24 (41.3%) hydatid cysts were found in the lung, liver and both organs, respectively. In the present study, the lungs of buffaloes were found to be more commonly infected with CE than livers, as previously reported by Khan & Haseeb (Reference Khan and Haseeb1984) and Khanmohammadi et al. (Reference Khanmohammadi, Gayem Maghami and Zakaria Zadeh2008).
Many researchers from various parts of the world have recorded different prevalences of CE in buffaloes. Epidemiological surveys have been conducted in Pakistan with prevalence rates ranging from 7.14 to 68% (Latif et al., Reference Latif, Tanveer, Maqbool, Siddiqi, Kyaw-Tanner and Traub2010); in India with prevalence rates ranging from 3.81 to 69.0% (Irshadullah et al., Reference Irshadullah, Nizami and Macpherson1989; Singh et al., Reference Singh, Sharma Deorani and Sirvastava1989; Pednekar et al., Reference Pednekar, Gatne, Thompson and Traub2009); in Nepal with a prevalence rate of 5% (Joshi et al., Reference Joshi, Joshi and Joshi1997); in Iraq with a prevalence rate of 6.57% (Al-Sultan & Jarjees, Reference Al-Sultan and Jarjees1999); in Egypt with a prevalence rate of 0.46% (Haridy et al., Reference Haridy, Ibrahim and Morsy1998); in Italy with a prevalence rate ranging from 8.7 to 12.4% (Capuano et al., Reference Capuano, Rinaldi, Maurelli, Perugini, Veneziano, Garippa, Genchi, Musella and Cringoli2006; Cringoli et al., Reference Cringoli, Veneziano, Rinaldi, Capuano and Garippa2006) and in Bangladesh with a prevalence rate of 45.2% (Islam, Reference Islam1982a, Reference Islamb).
Different rates of fertility may be due to the strain of the parasite. Hosseini (Reference Hosseini1997) recorded the prevalence of hydatidosis in sheep, goats and cattle as 7.1, 3.1 and 7.5%, respectively, and reported the fertility rate of hydatid cysts as 88, 13 and 61% in sheep, goats and cattle, respectively. Despite the relatively high rate of infection in buffaloes (9%), the fertility rate of cysts was low, as has been demonstrated in cattle (Hosseini, Reference Hosseini1997; Samavatian et al., Reference Samavatian, Valilou, Lotfi, Yousef Khani and Mirzaei2009). Our previous molecular study showed that 92% of hydatid cysts in buffaloes were of sheep origin (G1) and just 8% of cysts were of buffalo origin (G3) (Amin Pour et al., Reference Amin Pour, Hosseini and Shayan2011). Therefore, it seems that most of the infection in buffaloes with CE is of sheep origin and that the G3 strain has limited distribution in buffaloes in Iran. In addition, despite the relatively high rate of infection, due to the low fertility of CE in buffaloes, this animal may play a minor role in the epidemiology of hydatidosis in Iran.
Acknowledgements
We thank Dr Nurolahi, Dr Razbani, Dr Behruzi and Dr Alavi from the Veterinary Organization of Iran for their help for collecting the samples from different slaughterhouses.