The emerging, critical role of the medical specialty of physical medicine and rehabilitation (PM&R), also known as physiatry, in disaster response deserves notice in this global forum dedicated to integrating relevant medical specialty perspectives into disaster medicine and public health preparedness. Trauma rehabilitation, the rehabilitation of injuries associated with physical trauma, focuses on early rehabilitation interventions of injuries including traumatic brain injury, spinal cord injury (SCI), traumatic amputations, peripheral nerve injuries, multiple musculoskeletal trauma, and burns.Reference Robinson1 This commentary characterizes the role of PM&R during the response stage of several recent large-scale natural disasters including Hurricane Katrina, the 2005 Kashmir earthquake, the 2008 Sichuan earthquake and the 2010 Haiti earthquake. Relevant, significant disaster recovery and preparedness efforts are included as well.Reference Kano, Wood, Siegel and Bourque2
Hurricane Katrina, one of the deadliest and the most costly natural disaster in US history, made landfall along the Gulf Coast on August 29, 2005, resulting in catastrophic flooding and the forced evacuation of nearly 373 000 area residents.Reference Hamilton, Gavagan and Smart3 Many remaining residents sought emergency shelter in the Louisiana Superdome and the New Orleans Ernest N. Morial Convention Center, and because of a rapid decline in living conditions there were bused to the Reliant Park megashelter in Houston, where more than 11 000 people were treated in the “Katrina Clinic” during a 2-week period.Reference Chiou-Tan, Bloodworth and Kass4 Hamilton et al provide a detailed description of the clinic design, its operations, and supporting emergency command structure during the course of “Operation Dome Shelter” operations.Reference Hamilton, Gavagan and Smart3
Physiatrists evaluated and treated a range of musculoskeletal, dermatological, metabolic, and cardiovascular complaints in the Katrina Clinic; neurological diagnoses including subacute stroke and chronic spinal cord injuries were also managed. Care shifted from initial, immediate medical issues to chronic PM&R conditions including mobility deficits, wound care, catheterization, and pain pump refills.Reference Bloodworth, Kevorkian, Rumbaut and Chiou-Tan5 Chiou-Tan et al elaborated on the PM&R conditions that were treated at the Katrina Clinic via a retrospective chart analysis that showed 239 patients with 292 PM&R conditions.Reference Chiou-Tan, Bloodworth and Kass4 The most frequent PM&R conditions by diagnostic category were swollen feet and legs, leg pain and cramps, headache, and neck and back pain; the majority of the musculoskeletal arm, leg, and trunk diagnoses were described as pains, strains, sprains, pulls, and tendinitis/fasciitis, a pattern of injuries that is consistent with enduring stressful body postures and limited mobility for extended periods before arrival.
PM&R patient data and lessons learned from the Katrina Clinic informed forecasting of necessary durable medical equipment, consumable supplies, and specific medications, as well as creating staffing ratios and on-call schedules that included medical rehabilitation professionals.Reference Chiou-Tan, Bloodworth and Kass4 Katrina Clinic experience also demonstrated the critical need for PM&R to ensure that evacuation and transportation protocols and sheltering options for the disabled population are comprehensively addressed in municipal disaster planning. These preparedness points are highlighted in the recent American Academy of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation comments on the draft National Disaster Recovery Framework.6
Since Hurricane Katrina, catastrophic earthquakes have demonstrated a pattern of injury characterized by severe skull/traumatic brain injury, SCI, pelvis and extremity fractures, traumatic amputation with associated nerve injury and related internal injuries, and burn/inhalation injuries. Survival depends on rapid retrieval, triage, and transportation of survivors to a trauma center for definitive surgical care.Reference Gautschi, Cadosch, Rajan and Zellweger7
Long-term morbidity can be significantly reduced by the performance of early rehabilitation interventions by the rehabilitation traumatologist (ie, physiatrist as part of the intensive acute care team initially and then as head of the multidisciplinary medical rehabilitation team once the patient has transferred to the appropriate, specialized inpatient rehabilitation unit). Many earthquake survivors have multiple, severe impairments requiring comprehensive and protracted rehabilitation to achieve optimal physical functioning and reintegration into postdisaster society.
Indeed, experience from the 2005 Kashmir earthquake in which 79 000 people were killed and 106 000 were injured showed that the involvement of physiatrists in the management of SCI during the disaster response resulted in improved outcomes and reduced morbidity.Reference Rathore, Farooq, Butt and Gill8 Despite the lack of spinal trauma evacuation protocols and only 1 tertiary care rehabilitation institute in Pakistan, the many patients with SCI were successfully managed overall due to effective helicopter evacuation, rapid establishment of temporary spinal units, and augmentation by international SCI rehabilitation teams.Reference Rathore, Rashid, Butt, Malik, Gill and Haig9Reference Rathore, Farooq, Muzammil, New, Ahmed and Haig10
The 2008 earthquake in Sichuan Province resulted in at least 69 000 casualties, 374 000 injuries, and the displacement of 5 million people.11 At least 10 000 of the most severely injured were urgently transferred to major hospitals in 20 provinces, where early rehabilitation intervention was performed with generally positive results. However, postdischarge follow-up showed a reversal of functional gains and secondary complications in some SCI survivors due primarily to insufficient long-term, community-based rehabilitation (CBR) resources, according to Dr Jianan Li, vice chairman of the Chinese Association of Rehabilitation Medicine (personal communication, March 11, 2010). Chinese Ministry of Health CBR teams started working with survivors as they returned to their home communities several months after the earthquake amidst overwhelming need. A household survey of injured people from 21 townships in Mianzhu conducted from October to December 2008 showed that 88.4% (2021) required physical rehabilitation (Jean Van Wetter, Handicap International [HI] country director, China, personal communication, March 10, 2010).
International rehabilitation assistance has proven the most beneficial in postearthquake recovery because foreign nongovernmental organizations, including HI, are conducting CBR pilot projects whose potential positive impact will be achieved after full implementation. Although the international immediate earthquake response was prompt, effectiveness was limited by the participation of relatively few physiatrists and the language differences. Unfortunately, the rehabilitation needs of many earthquake survivors in Sichuan, especially children and those with SCI, remain critical, with long-term care uncertain, noted Dr Li.
On January 12, 2010, the earthquake in Haiti resulted in an estimated 217 000 casualties, 300 000 injuries, and 511 000 people displaced.12 Preliminary injury findings based on an assessment of 17 hospitals in the greater Port Au Prince area at 2 weeks after the earthquake indicated that approximately 80% of people presenting to hospitals had orthopaedic injuries, with lower extremity fractures predominating. SCIs constituted 6% of these injuries.13 A high prevalence of both primary and secondary amputations was noted; 2000 to 4000 people are estimated to have received amputations.14 Overwhelmed response team surgeons amputated urgently under austere conditions with minimal local material support.15 (By comparison, amputation decisions could be delayed in the Kashmir and Sichuan earthquakes because most of the hospitals were still functioning.)
HI and Christian Blind Mission are coleads of the United Nations–World Health Organization/Pan American Health Organization Haiti Health Cluster's Injury, Rehabilitation and Disability Workgroup (“disability subcluster”), which is responsible for coordinating all of the rehabilitation activities for injured and disabled people in Haiti.15161718 The workgroup serves as a forum for coordinating disability-related response efforts through onsite weekly meetings and an online presence.19 As part of the emergency response from HI, a physiatrist-led group of medical rehabilitation professionals from Healing Hands Haiti (HHH) United States/Canada with experience in Haiti augmented HI's mobile health teams. The HHH group directed acute rehabilitation interventions; monitored postoperative amputee and SCI care in area hospitals; provided necessary education to patients, families, and care providers; and trained local health workers in physical rehabilitation techniques.2021 Uncertain discharge plans for these patients, many without homes and families, raised significant concerns about their receiving appropriate wound and residual limb management in the community. An assessment of 30 amputees revealed only 1 patient who was physically qualified for a prosthetic fitting.22 Implementation of a standardized, community-level, prefitting program with appropriate therapy remains a significant challenge. The Injury, Rehabilitation and Disability workgroup and the Prosthetics and Orthotics subgroup are addressing this complicated issue, among others.23
North American physiatrists are deploying with medical relief nongovernmental organizations, including those that were working in Haiti before the earthquake, such as the HHH International Foundation,24 Project Medishare,25 and Partners in Health.26 The American Academy of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation recommends volunteering options to its members and also refers them to the American Medical Association/National Disaster Life Support Disaster Volunteer Physician Registry on its Web site.2728 Physiatrists from other countries including France, the Philippines,15 and CubaReference del Castillo29 are on the ground as well. Several North American physiatrists who work with Haitian rehabilitation service providers are collaboratively developing a plan to meet intermediate and long-term regional needs, as are other resident rehabilitation organizations with a permanent commitment to Haiti.30 North American physiatrists are also providing input into the draft National Plan for Disability and Rehab.31
This commentary describes the critical role of PM&R during the response stage of several recent large-scale natural disasters including Hurricane Katrina and the Kashmir, Sichuan Province, and Haitian earthquakes. Haiti has clearly demonstrated physiatrists' expertise in providing neurological and musculoskeletal short-term and postoperative care and leadership in developing supporting community-level rehabilitation programming and longer-term rehabilitative recovery planning. Increased physiatrist participation during the immediate earthquake response would have further improved triage effectiveness by identifying and managing traumatic injuries that required acute rehabilitation interventions and minimized surgical complications.
PM&R’s response during the 2010 Haitian earthquake will appropriately result in physiatrists being requested for immediate deployment with other traditional first responders in future large-scale natural disasters. The growing recognition of the immediate disaster response capability of PM&R by the global disaster medicine community must be further confirmed by physiatric disaster research and reinforced with strong advocacy by North American PM&R specialty organizations and international rehabilitation organizations including the International Rehabilitation Forum and the International Society of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine.3233
Author's Disclosures: The author reports no conflicts of interest.
Acknowledgements
The author gratefully acknowledges the participation of physiatrists Drs Donna Bloodworth, Faye Chiou-Tan, Andrew Haig, George Kevorkian, Jianan Li, Colleen O’Connell, Bryan O’Young, Farooq Rathore, and Mark Young in the PM&R response to the disasters referenced in this commentary.