Crossref Citations
This article has been cited by the following publications. This list is generated based on data provided by
Crossref.
McGowan, Iain W.
Fisher, Naomi
Havens, Justin
and
Proudlock, Simon
2021.
An evaluation of eye movement desensitization and reprocessing therapy delivered remotely during the Covid–19 pandemic.
BMC Psychiatry,
Vol. 21,
Issue. 1,
Malolos, Grace Zurielle C.
Baron, Maria Beatriz C.
Apat, Faith Ann J.
Sagsagat, Hannah Andrea A.
Pasco, Pamela Bianca M.
Aportadera, Emma Teresa Carmela L.
Tan, Roland Joseph D.
Gacutno-Evardone, Angelica Joyce
and
Lucero-Prisno III, Don Eliseo
2021.
Mental health and well-being of children in the Philippine setting during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Health Promotion Perspectives,
Vol. 11,
Issue. 3,
p.
267.
Alkaissi, Aidah
Zaben, Fadi
Abu-Rajab, Mohammad
and
Alkony, Mahdia
2022.
Lived experiences of Palestinian patients with COVID-19: a multi-center descriptive phenomenological study of recovery journey.
BMC Public Health,
Vol. 22,
Issue. 1,
Medved, Sara
Imširagić, Azijada Srkalović
Salopek, Igor
Puljić, Dragan
Handl, Hrvoje
Kovač, Marina
Peleš, Alma Mihaljević
Štimac Grbic, Danijela
Romančuk, Luka
MuŽić, Roberto
Zeeman, Laura Shields
and
Kuzman, Martina Rojnić
2022.
Case Series: Managing Severe Mental Illness in Disaster Situation: the Croatian Experience After 2020 Earthquake.
Frontiers in Psychiatry,
Vol. 12,
Issue. ,
Ji, Julie L.
Basanovic, Julian
and
MacLeod, Colin
2022.
Social activity promotes resilience against loneliness in depressed individuals: a study over 14-days of physical isolation during the COVID-19 pandemic in Australia.
Scientific Reports,
Vol. 12,
Issue. 1,
Lenton, Timothy M.
Boulton, Chris A.
and
Scheffer, Marten
2022.
Resilience of countries to COVID-19 correlated with trust.
Scientific Reports,
Vol. 12,
Issue. 1,
Aruta, John Jamir Benzon R.
Salcedo, Sena S.
Guilaran, Johnrev
and
Guinto, Renzo R.
2022.
The plight and promise of mental health providers in the face of a warming planet: perspectives and experiences from the Philippines.
International Review of Psychiatry,
Vol. 34,
Issue. 5,
p.
530.
Sayarifard, Azadeh
Nazari, Maryam
Rajabi, Fatemeh
Ghadirian, Laleh
and
Sajadi, Haniye Sadat
2022.
Identifying the non-governmental organizations' activities and challenges in response to the COVID-19 pandemic in Iran.
BMC Public Health,
Vol. 22,
Issue. 1,
Ide-Okochi, Ayako
Samiso, Tomonori
Kanamori, Yumie
He, Mu
Sakaguchi, Mika
and
Fujimura, Kazumi
2022.
Depression, Insomnia, and Probable Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder among Survivors of the 2016 Kumamoto Earthquake and Related Factors during the Recovery Period Amidst the COVID-19 Pandemic.
International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,
Vol. 19,
Issue. 7,
p.
4403.
Rocha, Ian Christopher N.
Ramos, Kimberly G.
and
Crispino, Kevin T.
2022.
Food and Waterborne Disease Outbreaks after a Super Typhoon Hit the Southern Philippines during the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Triple Public Health Emergency.
Prehospital and Disaster Medicine,
Vol. 37,
Issue. 3,
p.
421.
Corriero, Anna Chiara
Khan, Fatima Muhammad Asad
Bassey, Esther Edet
Bouaddi, Oumnia
dos Santos Costa, Ana Carla
Outani, Oumaima
Hasan, Mohammad Mehedi
Ahmad, Shoaib
and
Essar, Mohammad Yasir
2022.
Floods, landslides and COVID-19 in the Uttarakhand State, India: Impact of Ongoing Crises on Public Health.
Disaster Medicine and Public Health Preparedness,
Vol. 16,
Issue. 6,
p.
2279.
Kusonwattana, Poonyawat
Ong, Ardvin Kester S.
Prasetyo, Yogi Tri
Mariñas, Klint Allen
Yuduang, Nattakit
Chuenyindee, Thanatorn
Thana, Kriengkrai
Persada, Satria Fadil
Nadlifatin, Reny
and
Robas, Kirstien Paola E.
2022.
Predicting Factors Affecting the Intention to Prepare for Mitigation of Man-Made Fire Disasters in Chonburi Province, Thailand: An Integration of Structural Equation Modeling and Artificial Neural Network Hybrid Approach.
Sustainability,
Vol. 14,
Issue. 22,
p.
15442.
Cordero, Dalmacito A.
2023.
Letter to the Editor: Strengthening the Disaster Response of the Philippines for a Better Healthcare System.
Journal of Preventive Medicine and Public Health,
Vol. 56,
Issue. 2,
p.
200.
Priyantini, Diah
Ayatulloh, Daviq
Sukartini, Tintin
and
Nursalam
2023.
Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference of Health Innovation and Technology (ICHIT 2022).
Vol. 64,
Issue. ,
p.
80.
Medved, Sara
Palavra, Irena Rojnić
Gerlach, Josefina
Levaj, Sarah
Shields-Zeeman, Laura
Bolinski, Felix
Bradaš, Zoran
Madžarac, Zoran
Filipčić, Igor
and
Rojnić Kuzman, Martina
2023.
Changes in substance use and engagement in gaming/gambling in persons with severe mental illness during the COVID-19 pandemic and earthquakes: a community study in two points.
Frontiers in Psychiatry,
Vol. 14,
Issue. ,
Cordero, Dalmacito A
2023.
Rescuing the Rescuers: the essential role of recognition for the mental health of emergency rescuers.
Annals of Work Exposures and Health,
Vol. 67,
Issue. 9,
p.
1125.
Kamboh, Shafiq Ahmad
Ittefaq, Muhammad
and
Pezzullo, Phaedra C.
2024.
Articulating a Loss and Damage Fund: How the Global South is Rethinking Agency and Justice in an Age of Climate Disasters.
Environmental Communication,
Vol. 18,
Issue. 3,
p.
302.
Hechanova-Alampay, Ma. Regina
Angeles, Patrick Louis
Tuliao, Antover
Hilario, Edgar
Pagente, Amadeus Fernando
and
Narra, Carol Villegas
2024.
The development and pilot evaluation of a mental health mobile app in the Philippines.
Mental Health and Social Inclusion,
Vol. 28,
Issue. 5,
p.
370.
Md. Ripul, Kabir
and
Md. Rabiul, Islam
2024.
Factors of negative psychic state, anxiety, and depression of waterlogged farmers in Bangladesh: A farming disaster.
i-manager's Journal on Humanities & Social Sciences,
Vol. 4,
Issue. 3,
p.
21.
Alibudbud, Rowalt C.
Aruta, John Jamir Benzon R.
Sison, Kevin Anthony
and
Guinto, Renzo R.
2024.
Artificial intelligence in the era of planetary health: insights on its application for the climate change-mental health nexus in the Philippines.
International Review of Psychiatry,
p.
1.
Introduction
The Philippines, a Southeast Asian archipelagic country with 7641 islands, 1 has experienced a vast number of deadly disasters, such as recurrent typhoons, earthquakes, floods, storm surges, volcanic eruptions, and other natural disasters. 2,Reference Wingard and Brändlin3 This is the reason why it was dubbed the third most disaster-prone country in the world, behind Tonga and Vanuatu. Reference Wingard and Brändlin3–Reference Sanchez5 Annually, an average of 20 typhoons hit the country, 5 of which are devastating. 6,7
More than 100 million residents are exposed to an extensive variety of natural disasters due to 4 main factors. 8,Reference Vergano9 First and foremost is the country’s geographical location on the Pacific’s earthquake and volcano Ring of Fire, making it very susceptible to natural disasters. 7,Reference Vergano9 Second factor is its warm ocean waters with a temperature of above 28°C, which may trigger typhoons to form. Reference Vergano9–Reference Thompson11 Located just above the equator in the Western Pacific, the country is surrounded by the warmest ocean temperatures in the globe. 7,Reference Vergano9 Third factor is the country’s deforestation problem which triggers mudslides and flash floods. Reference Vergano9,12 The last factor is the country’s social vulnerability. Many poor Filipinos who live on low-lying coastal islands are most vulnerable to disasters. Reference Vergano9,Reference Morin, Ahmad and Warnitchai13,14
In 2020, the Philippines was hit by a total of 22 tropical cyclones in the middle of a pandemic. 7 Among the 22 tropical cyclones, there were 5 tropical depressions, 7 tropical storms, 3 severe tropical storms, 6 typhoons, and 1 super typhoon. 7 On May 14, 2020, when the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic had already resulted in 11 876 cases in the country, the first tropical cyclone for the year, Typhoon Vongfong (locally known as Typhoon Ambo), hit the Philippines and devastated areas of the country’s east coast. Reference Lucero-Prisno, Bernardino and Camua15,16 In less than 12 hours, it transformed from a strong tropical storm to a Category 3 typhoon, with heavy rains and winds of 96 mph that caused floods, landslides, power cuts, knocked down trees, countless roofs, in addition to damaging homes and infrastructure in the region, leaving thousands of people homeless, because they lived in areas at risk. 16
Six months after the first tropical cyclone in 2020 landed in the country, the Philippines was struck by Super Typhoon Goni (locally known as Super Typhoon Rolly), the strongest tropical cyclone in world history, with rains and winds of 195 mph, on November 1, 2020. Reference Madarang17 Twelve regions in the Philippines, with a total population of 68.6 million, were reported to be affected by the Category 5 super typhoon. Reference Aguilar18–20 Among the 12 regions, the Bicol region, specifically the provinces of Catanduanes and Albay, was greatly devastated. Reference Aguilar18
The effects of this climatic disturbance were devastating and enhanced due to the current pandemic. During the landfall of Typhoon Vongfong, around 61 000 families were assigned to 2332 shelters in the Bicol region, and 13 000 people were evacuated in the Samar region, 21 while during the landfall of Super Typhoon Goni, around 400 000 individuals were displaced in the Bicol region. Reference Gutierrez and Beech22 Repetitive typhoons in the Philippines during the pandemic have laid the bricks for an everlasting humanitarian crisis as more than 305 000 houses and collateral assets have been damaged or destroyed. 23 Therefore, the scenarios facing the typhoon passage demanded immediate evacuation; however, due to isolation and social distancing, these actions were hindered. 16 Authorities tried to avoid agglomerations as much as possible at evacuation sites to ensure compliance with measures of social distance and hygiene, in addition to checking body temperature and the presence of symptoms of COVID-19. Other strategies included sending packages of food to municipalities that could suffer from a shortage of supplies. Reference Lucero-Prisno, Bernardino and Camua15,21,Reference Kaufman24
In many instances, natural disasters can cause physical, mental, and social health problems, wherein poor mental health is more frequently reported. Reference Makwana25 However, when natural disasters are added to an ongoing pandemic, this combined situation may overwhelm and devastate many individuals, leading to poorer mental health. Thus, this article aims to address the effects of natural disasters on the mental health of Filipinos during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Discussion
As the Philippines is known to be hit by at least 20 typhoons every year, 7 delayed mental health effects have been noticed more often than immediate effects. The worst typhoon in the Philippines’ natural disaster history recorded before the recent Super Typhoon Goni was Super Typhoon Haiyan (locally known as Super Typhoon Yolanda) that hit in November 2013. Reference Madarang17,Reference McPherson, Counahan and Hall26 Studies reported that the mental health of Filipinos after Super Typhoon Haiyan has reasoned out the delay in manifestations of mental instability. At the time of disaster, surviving the worst and escaping the worst occupy the victims. Post-rescue, when a safe space is reached, which is after a period of 3 to 6 months, is when the mental component enters. Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), depression, and anxiety were reported after Super Typhoon Haiyan, and the same could be expected now. Reference Geronimo27
With the added pandemic, adjustment problems and irrational fears, shock, and hopelessness are worse this time, compared with previous disasters in the Philippines. A constant state of despair is also seen in the victims, which is stirring the mental health of the population. The burden of losing a loved one and the effect of realizing it later, displacement of family, socio-economic loss, environmental loss, and lack of mental preparedness and social support with negative coping skills, such as substance abuse, may induce psychological stress. Reference Makwana25 One important cause of this is the non-availability of medications for people who were already on drugs for pre-existing mental health problems, which aggravates their condition. Reference Geronimo27
Moreover, the effect of pandemics on mental health has also been studied frequently during the COVID-19 pandemic. It was stated in a study conducted within the early portion of 2020 that a minimum of 3.6 million Filipinos suffer from a type of mental, neurological, and substance use disorder. 28 Thus, one can conclude that the COVID-19 pandemic has had a very detrimental effect on mental health, leading to depression, anxiety, severe stress, and high suicidal tendencies in the general population all over the world. Reference Cleofas and Rocha29,Reference Xiong, Lipsitz and Nasri30
In the Philippines, many studies were conducted to assess the correlation between the pandemic and mental health of Filipinos. One study concluded that around 17% have moderate-to-severe depressive symptoms, whereas around 30% reported to have moderate-to-severe anxiety levels, and around 14% had moderate-to-severe stress levels. Reference Tee, Tee and Anlacan31 Cases for mental health conditions, especially depression, anxiety, and severe stress significantly spiked up. A rise in suicide rates, increased by 25.7% in 2020, was a major concern. Reference Rivas32 Although the Philippines has consistently ranked in the top 5 of a worldwide optimism index, the National Center for Mental Health (NCMH) has revealed a huge rise in monthly hotline calls about depression, with numbers increasing from just 80 calls before lockdown to about 400. 33
Many factors having an adverse effect on mental health during the pandemic were identified, which include younger than age 30, female gender, well-educated, unmarried or separated, prolonged home stay, excessive worries about COVID-19, and association with people who have already contracted the disease. Protective factors, on the other hand, included male gender, staying within a joint family especially with children, having confidence in one’s own ability to make it through the pandemic as well as one’s health care professionals, having employment, and hand hygiene. Reference Tee, Tee and Anlacan31,Reference Wang, Tee and Roy34
Since the passing of the country’s Mental Health Act, the comprehensive and integrated approach has been practiced. Reference Lally, Tully and Samaniego35 To incorporate community involvement and provide a holistic approach, 3 main ideas have been highlighted, such as incorporation of culture in intervention program by ensuring audience appropriate language usage for the material and methodology used, participatory approaches by implying the utilization of community for both the delivery as well as the reception of the intervention, and evolving role of competent community psychologists who will empower the community by understanding and managing the stakeholders. Reference Lally, Tully and Samaniego35 The importance of community-based intervention is felt since mental health is still stigmatized in the Philippines. Thus, involving the community in designing, delivering, and training would be a more agreeable approach.
Realizing this, the government of the Philippines introduced a multi-sectoral approach for mental health in a variety of settings, such as in offices, colleges, schools, and hospitals. 36 These include National Suicide Prevention Strategy, NCMH’s 24/7 hotline, and World Suicide Prevention Day to raise awareness. Collaborating with the government, the World Health Organization urges Filipinos to have conversations about mental health and highlights the need for empathy by listening to those affected. 33 Moreover, US $12 billion will be allocated to the purchase and distribution of COVID-19 vaccines in developing countries, including the Philippines, by the World Bank Group. 37 The Office of Civil Defense and the National Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Council are also working to build preparedness within residents by encouraging sanitation and social distancing during the disaster to help improve safety within temporary shelters. Reference Mendoza38
At the communal level, local initiatives are working to address mental health needs of the general population through training programs and requests to build more mental health facilities. A scarcity of well-trained psychiatrists exists in communal settings, which allows locals to find alternatives to training workers in identifying and managing mental health concerns, especially trauma. Reference Estrada, Usami and Satake39 One such example is the initiative by the regional office of the Department of Health (DOH) in Bicol which aims to train workers in rural and city areas to manage mental health concerns within their communities. The DOH has also requested the local government units to increase mental health institutes like Don Susano Rodriguez Memorial Mental Hospital in Pili as such institutes are few in number in the region and in the country. Reference Toledo40 In addition, the local government units in Bicol, with the assistance of the Department of Education, conducted therapeutic sessions on psychological well-being and mental support programs to assist the locals in recovering from trauma and anxiety caused by the recurrent catastrophic typhoons and current pandemic. Reference Balala41 Teachers were also identified as key players in addressing mental health issues of children and hence initiatives to provide psychological first aid training to them are helping address their mental health needs. Reference Estrada, Usami and Satake39
Other suggestions include the use of telemedicine to help navigate the burden of mental health issues, and implementation of disaster risk reduction management and psychological interventions to Filipinos who were greatly affected by both natural disasters and the COVID-19 pandemic. Reference Ćosić, Popović, Šarlija and Kesedžić42,43 Psychological interventions include coping strategies, psychological first aid, debriefing, cognitive behavioral therapy, psychosocial support, and community-based interventions. 44,Reference Math, Nirmala, Moirangthem and Kumar45 In addition, it is necessary that primary health care services, which constitute the most frequent contact of a greater part of the population, integrate aspects of mental health care, with a focus on previous diagnosis, prevention, and treatment of mental disorders in the community, as well as in the development of educational and awareness campaigns on the topic. Such integration is also necessary, because during the pandemic and in situations of public emergency, such services are the main form of care for patients with psychiatric diseases, due to the difficulty of accessing some services. In this scenario, more substantial financing by the government is also needed, with the objective of expanding and giving greater autonomy to primary care services, through the training of professionals to work in the initial management of mental disorders. Strategies like these can assist not only in the treatment of pre-existing mental illnesses, but also in reducing the incidence of new psychiatric disorders.
Conclusion
To conclude, the Philippines is undergoing a humanitarian crisis amidst a pandemic, which is causing detrimental impacts on the mental health of Filipinos. The Philippines experienced many natural disasters during the pandemic primarily due to its geographical location and warm ocean temperatures. Typhoons in 2020 had devastating infrastructural impacts on an already poverty-stricken country, with the addition of a growing COVID-19 pandemic. Loss of basic amenities, homelessness, financial stress, and lack of social distancing in evacuation centers were prevailing factors to mental instability. Among the psychological impacts, depression, anxiety, and PTSD were increasing within a population that already had high mental health problems. Nonetheless, international agencies and the government are making efforts to recover through the creation of economic opportunities, provision of COVID-19 vaccines, and mental health support services.
Author Contributions
ICNR conceived the idea and design; wrote the abstract, introduction, and discussion; organized the list of references; and edited the final draft. ACdSC wrote the introduction and discussion, and made critical comments and revision. ZI wrote the discussion and conclusion, and edited the final draft. SJ wrote the discussion. SG wrote the discussion. PM wrote the discussion. MYE made the critical comments and revision. SA edited the final draft. All authors revised and approved the final manuscript.
Conflict(s) of Interest
The authors declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this paper.