Congenital heart defects are serious anomalies that account for nearly one-third of all major congenital anomaliesReference Van der Linde, Konings and Slager 1 and have a major impact on paediatric morbidity, mortality, and health-care costs.Reference Botto, Correa and Erickson 2 The internationally accepted birth incidence of congenital heart disease is 8‰, although large variations in data occur across studies.Reference Hoffman and Kaplan 3 In general, it is argued that the birth incidence of congenital heart disease has remained stable over time.Reference Hoffman and Kaplan 3 , Reference Wren, Richmond and Donaldson 4
In developing countries, congenital heart disease may go unrecognised, resulting in serious morbidity and high mortality rate.Reference Kuehl, Loffredo and Ferencz 5
Tunisia is considered among the emerging countries, and since 1970 the government has focused on rheumatic fever, which benefited from an outreach programme. Thus, the incidence of rheumatic fever decreased dramatically. On the contrary, congenital heart defects are diagnosed more frequently, and the number of operated children is increasing. Unfortunately, surgical treatment of neonatal and complex congenital heart disease in Tunisia remains limited.Reference Stolf 6
Indeed, congenital heart defects represent a public health concern with a heavy economic burden owing to the cost of surgery sometimes carried out repeatedly.
In Tunisia, unfortunately, we do not have precise data of the incidence of congenital heart disease due to the lack of a national registry. Therefore, we continue to ignore those data in our population.
Through this study, we aimed to investigate the birth incidence and mortality rate among children with congenital heart disease born in 2010 and 2011 in Sfax.
Methods
Study population
This population-based study was conducted in Sfax. Sfax is the second largest city in Tunisia with a high population density – 944,500 inhabitants. In our city, 60% of children are born in hospitals and receive a systematic check up from a physician before discharge and when they are 40 days old.
There is only one tertiary care public centre for cardiology that includes paediatric cardiology. Thus, the cases of children with congenital heart disease in Sfax have been evaluated by a paediatric cardiologist either in our public hospital or in the private sector. Hence, all patients registered in our database and those whose cases have been evaluated by our colleagues in the private sector were eligible for inclusion.
Unfortunately, the stillbirths have not been autopsied systematically. However, we included cases of stillbirth with foetal diagnosis of severe congenital heart disease and also cases of antenatal diagnosis of heart defect with postnatal death of within a few hours.
We also asked the department of forensic medicine for cases of children with congenital heart disease.
Definitions
Data were retrospectively retrieved from the medical records. We included gender, date of birth, address, cardiac diagnosis, interventions, and eventual death.
Patients with the following defects were excluded: isolated patent foramen ovale not requiring closure; rhythm disturbances without structural defects; isolated mild peripheral pulmonary stenosis; isolated patent ductus arteriosus not requiring closure; patent ductus arteriosus in preterm infants and in neonates with delay of closure; hereditary disorders without cardiac consequences; and malpositioning of the heart without structural defects. On the other hand, isolated patent ductus arteriosus requiring either a surgical closure or percutaneous closure are included.
Classification of congenital heart diseaseReference Riehle-Colarusso, Strickland and Reller 7 , Reference Reller, Strickland and Riehle-Colarusso 8
The left to right shunt includes ventricular septal defects, atrial septal defects, persistence of ductus arteriosus, complete atrioventricular septal defect, atrial septal defect-type Ostium primum, and atrial septal defect-type sinus venosus with or without abnormal venous return.
The cyanotic congenital heart defects include tetralogy of Fallot, pulmonary atresia with ventricular septal defect, transposition of the great arteries, discordant atrioventricular connections, truncus arteriosus, total anomalous pulmonary venous return, tricuspid atresia, Ebstein's anomaly, single ventricle complex, and heterotaxy syndrome.
Left heart obstructive defects include coarctation of the aorta, valvar aortic stenosis, interrupted aortic arch, and hypoplastic left heart syndrome.
Right heart obstructive defects include pulmonary stenosis and pulmonary atresia without ventricular septal defect.
As a considerable number of patients had more than one heart defect, a hierarchic system of classification was adopted, which allowed the inclusion of each patient in only one diagnostic category.Reference Wren, Richmond and Donaldson 4 We used an anatomical hierarchy, based mainly on anatomical severity, and where there were two or more malformations within the same diagnostic group – left to right shunt especially – we chose the heart defect that required intervention.
To calculate the birth incidence of congenital heart disease and specific heart defects, we needed birth rate information for 2010 and 2011 in Sfax, which was given by the national institute of statistics. Owing to the fact that this study used existing and anonymous data, no informed consent was required.
Results
Birth incidence
In 2010 and 2011, 37,294 births were registered in Sfax. We recorded 255 children with congenital heart disease born in 2010–2011. This yielded a birth incidence of congenital heart disease of 6.8 per 1000 births (Table 1). We also included one case of stillbirth with a foetal diagnosis of hypoplastic left heart syndrome.
Table 1 Incidence of congenital heart diseases at birth.
ASD = atrial septal defect; CHD = congenital heart disease; VSD = ventricular septal defect.
By far, the most frequent heart malformation was ventricular septal defect, which accounted for almost 31% of all cases. There were five additional categories of heart malformation – atrial septal defects, atrioventricular septal defect, pulmonary stenosis, coarctation of the aorta, and persistent ductus arteriosus – that occurred in 4–12% of all heart malformations. Hypoplastic left heart, transposition of the great arteries, and tetralogy of Fallot occurred in 1.1%, 2.7%, and 6.2% of all heart defects, respectively. Double-outlet right ventricle was shown to exist in two children (0.78%) and single ventricle/tricuspid atresia in 3.4% of all heart malformations. Truncus arteriosus and pulmonary atresia with intact ventricular septum occurred in 0.4% and 0.7% of heart malformations, respectively.
Of the children with congenital heart disease, 134 were girls (52%) and 121 were boys (48%).
Circumstances of discovery and age at diagnosis of congenital heart disease
Patients with congenital heart disease were referred for many reasons ranging from simple murmur to severe symptoms (Fig 1).
Figure 1 Circumstances of discovery of congenital heart disease.
Foetal diagnosis occurred in only 13 cases: three cases of single ventricle, one case of hypoplastic left heart syndrome, one case of transposition of the great arteries, two cases of tetralogy of Fallot, five cases of atrioventricular septal defect, and one case of double-outlet right ventricle.
The mean age of infants at first contact was 0.29 years. About 21% of cardiac anomaly was diagnosed at <1 week of age and 34% at <1 month of age. In all, 54% were diagnosed between 1 month and 1 year of age, and only 11% were diagnosed at >1 year of age.
Treatment
A total of 77 children were born with ventricular septal defect. Only 24 required surgery, that is, 31% of total ventricular septal defects. Of these, 14 patients underwent surgery; 12 cases were successful and two patients died in the post-operative period. There were eight patients with large ventricular septal defect who died before reaching surgery. The reasons for these eight deaths were hospital infections in the majority of cases.
A total of 23 children were born with a complete or incomplete defect of the atrioventricular septum. Down syndrome was present in 13 children (56%). In children with a complete form of this anomaly (12 cases), surgery was performed in five cases, with one death in the post-operative period. Death occurred in six children before surgery.
Tetralogy of Fallot is the most frequent cyanotic congenital heart defect in our study; it was present in 16 cases. There were two children who died in the first half year before surgery: one case with very tight pulmonary stenosis and the second case was agenesis of the pulmonary valve in a premature child. In all, six children underwent surgery with success in Tunisia until the end of this study.
Transposition of the great arteries is the second cyanotic congenital heart defect. There were seven children with this anomaly. Only one case had benefited from foetal diagnosis. All patients but one were treated with the Rashkind procedure. The mean age at diagnosis was 24 days (from 1 day to 71 days). The survivors were not operated on in Tunisia, as this surgery is not available in our country.
In all, 11 children were born with coarctation of the aorta, with nine having a neonatal form diagnosed before the age of 2 months. The latter anomaly was associated with ventricular septal defect in six cases. The mortality rate in this congenital heart defect reached 70%. There were five patients with coarctation of the aorta who died within few days after surgery; these surgeries were performed in Tunisia.
Mortality
During the follow-up period of 1 year, 60 children (23.5%) died. The majority of these were boys (52%). Most children in this group died during the first 6 months of life. Table 2 describes the mortality rate according to the primary diagnosis and shows a striking difference in mortality between heart defects. The reasons for deaths were cardiac failure in 24 children, post-operative complications in 12 cases, sudden death in one case, and pulmonary complications, especially respiratory infections, in 21 cases. Infective endocarditis was fatal in two cases: one child with restrictive ventricular septal defect with immunity disorder and another child with successfully operated interruption of the aorta.
Table 2 Description of mortality cases according to the primary diagnosis.
ASD = atrial septal defect; VSD = ventricular septal defect.
Discussion
Several epidemiological studies on congenital heart disease in children have been completed to date. The majority of these studies relied on data collected by national registries in developed countries. In Tunisia, and with regard to the extent of coronary artery disease, congenital heart disease seems to be orphan. Thus, this study has the merit to be the first one that gives an estimation of the incidence of congenital heart disease. This was possible, first, because of computerisation of all reports of echocardiography in our tertiary department, and second because of a real collaboration between cardiologists in both public and private sectors.
Epidemiological data
The birth incidence of congenital heart disease of 6.8 per 1000 births in the present study is in line with the general estimates in the world.Reference Hoffman and Kaplan 3 Nonetheless, this incidence is lower than that usually found in Europe,Reference Dolk, Loane and Garne 9 for which the average incidence is 8‰. It would be closer to those found in other developing countries,Reference Vaidyanathan, Sathish and Mohanan 10 , Reference Samanek and Voriskova 11 where the lack of national registry and population-based surveys hampers such a comparison.
To determine the birth prevalence of congenital heart disease in our sample, we included young patients who were diagnosed within their first 2 years of life (2010–2011). Therefore, with this approach, we definitely missed about 8% of heart defects that diagnosed after the age of 5.Reference Wren and O'Sullivan 12 It is obvious that the prevalence found in our study is an underestimate one.
The prevalence of heart defects found in our study is consistent with that of previous reports. As in other studies, ventricular septal defects, atrial septal defects, and pulmonary valve abnormalities were the most frequently occurring heart defects.Reference Samanek and Voriskova 11 , Reference Bosi, Garani, Scorrano and Calzolari 13 – Reference Moons, Sluysmans and De Wolf 16 Ventricular septal defects was the most prevalent heart defect in our study, accounting for 31%. The high prevalence of ventricular septal defects in our study and in other reports might be due to the fact that they show clinical signs and symptoms, for example heart murmur.
Comparing our rates with those in the meta-analysis of Hoffman,Reference Hoffman and Kaplan 3 it may be noted that frequencies of coarctation of the aorta (4.3 versus 4.09) and transposition of the great arteries (2.7 versus 3.1) are consistent with those reported. However, atrioventricular septal defect (9.7 versus 3.4), tetralogy of Fallot (6.2 versus 4.2), pulmonary atresia (3.4 versus 1.3), and univentricular physiology (3.4 versus 1.7) exceeded the rates observed. These high rates could be explained by some overriding risk factors in our city such as consanguinity, diabetes, and above all air pollution. In fact, Sfax is an industrialised city with high exposure to air pollutants – nitrogen dioxide (NO2), sulfur dioxide (SO2), particulate matter (PM10) and ozone (O3). 17 Pollution has been recognised as a congenital heart defect risk factor in some recent studies.Reference Ritz, Yu, Fruin, Chapa, Shaw and Harris 18 , Reference Vrijheid, Martinez and Manzanares 19
Therefore, the diagnosis of different types of congenital heart disease was made not only for most common ones, but also for the complex anomalies and less frequent ones despite the socio-economic level of the population of developing countries. Unfortunately, prenatal diagnosis occurred in only 5%, which is far inferior to that observed at the European study (20.2%).Reference Dolk, Loane and Garne 9
Treatment and mortality
Data on mortality from congenital heart disease must be interpreted in the context of the medical and surgical care available in the region studied.Reference Mocumbi, Lameira, Yaksh, Paul, Ferreira and Sidi 20
The differences in mortality between the industrialised countries and third-world countries are striking, from 3–7% to 20%, respectively. The mortality rate in Belgium did not exceed 4% in a recent study.Reference Moons, Sluysmans and De Wolf 16 Significantly high mortality rates have been found in recent reports from African countries.Reference Mocumbi, Lameira, Yaksh, Paul, Ferreira and Sidi 20 , Reference Awori, Ogendo, Gitome, Ong'uti and Obonyo 21 The case fatality rate in our study was high, about 23%, which corresponds to the habitual rate found in the developing countries such as Guatemala and Sri Lanka.Reference Trucco, Barnoya, Larrazabal, Castañeda and Teitel 22 , Reference Wickramasinghe, Lamabadusuriya and Narenthiran 23 However, it must be considered that with improvement in diagnostic methods the total number of congenital heart disease cases has increased to include less serious or subclinical defects, thus decreasing the relative, but not absolute, mortality.Reference Mocumbi, Lameira, Yaksh, Paul, Ferreira and Sidi 20 Furthermore, the mortality from congenital heart disease is possibly under-reported in third-world nations because access to diagnosis is more difficult, and the great majority of studies only report data from patients in tertiary centres.Reference Mocumbi, Lameira, Yaksh, Paul, Ferreira and Sidi 20
Among the 23% of mortality cases, about three-quarters were observed before undergoing surgery. It may be explained by the initially severe clinical presentation of the patient, which evolved rapidly to death. In addition, socio-economic status and the parents’ educational level can influence the consultation time and the speed of the management of the child's case. However, the lack of a near and well-equipped cardiothoracic surgical centre could be a reason for this striking rate of death. In fact, malnourished and hypotrophic children are exposed to respiratory infections while awaiting surgery. In addition, the surgical delay can affect the patient's clinical condition and worsen the prognosis. For example, larger defects – ventricular septal defect – may lead to congestive heart failure, and infants succumb in the early months of life either to cardiac failure or to superimposed respiratory infection.
The reduction in mortality from congenital heart disease, which has been described in the western countries in the last 25 years, can be largely ascribed to three main factors: (1) an increase in prenatal diagnosis of serious disorders and subsequent terminationsReference Kovalchin and Silverman 24 ; (2) better early diagnosis and access to tertiary care centre of severe congenital heart disease; and (3) large advances in therapeutics, both medical and surgical. This could be a lesson for the governments in developing countries such as ours.
Limitations
Our study has several limitations, and results should be interpreted with caution. First, we included live births in which congenital heart disease was detected – only one stillbirth was included because a known diagnosis of hypoplastic left heart syndrome. In fact, stillbirths are not consistently autopsied, and the frequency of congenital heart disease in this subgroup is unknown. Second, subclinical heart defects are missed as a systematic screening of the entire population is not done. In fact, with high frequency of consanguinity, we could expect higher incidence than industrialised countries, this discrepancy could be explained by misdiagnosed cases. Third, our study included young children, and thus we missed about 8% of congenital heart disease generally diagnosed after the age of 5 years.Reference Wren and O'Sullivan 12
Conclusion
Through this study, we have shown a birth prevalence of congenital heart disease of 6.8 per 1000 births. Both the birth prevalence of congenital heart disease and the prevalence of specific heart defects are consistent with international data. However, the mortality rate is striking. Hence, there is an urgent need for the government to establish a well-equipped cardiothoracic surgical and paediatric cardiology unit.Reference Yacoub 25 Moreover, foetal and neonatal outreach programmes should be implemented, especially in less-favoured regions in the country.
Finally, there is a need to properly identify the extent of this global health problem by determining its true incidence. This can be done by conducting a national study or national registry. This kind of a database will be definitely more convincing.
Acknowledgements
The authors are grateful to all participants. They thank all the doctors in the private sector for their help. They also thank Mr Bahloul Ahmad for his critical reading of the paper.
