No CrossRef data available.
Article contents
How Consumer Law in Japan Shapes Religion: “Spiritual Sales” as a Legal Category
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 14 March 2025
Abstract
Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.
A core issue for media outlets and politicians since the assassination of Abe Shinzō has been monetary transactions between religious organizations and their current or former members. Anxieties surrounding religion's role in the public sphere have informed legal arguments about consumer issues. A category of fraud called “spiritual sales” has become a particular concern. In this article, I describe how interpretations of consumer law have been instrumental in dealing with spiritual sales and I discuss reasons why problematic consumption practices associated with religions that have attracted intense criticism have led the Japanese government to comprehensively revise regulatory protections as they reassess consumer vulnerabilities.
- Type
- Research Article
- Information
- Copyright
- Copyright © The Authors 2024
References
Anonymous. 1989. ォウム真理教教袓•麻原彰晃 氏：「宗教の観念から離れて実践へ」 [Aum Shinrikyō Founder Shōko Asahara: “Moving Away from Religious Notions into Practice”]. 朝日ジャーナル [Asahi Jānaru] 31(57): 17–18.Google Scholar
Asahi. 2022a. “Relative: Mother of Abe Murder Suspect Donated 100 Million Yen.” Asahi Shimbun, July 14, https://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/14669722.Google Scholar
Asahi. 2022b. “Unification Church: Murder Suspect's Mother Still a Member.” Asahi Shimbun, July 12, https://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/14667821.Google Scholar
Asahi. 2022c. “Suspect in Abe Slaying Tried to Kill Self So Kin Would Get Payout.” Asahi Shimbun, July 16, https://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/14671731.Google Scholar
Asahi. 2022d. “Politicians Come Out With Dealings with Unification Church.” Asahi Shimbun, July 26, https://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/14679765.Google Scholar
Asahi. 2022e. “People Born Into Unification Church Speak Out About Hardships.” Asahi Shimbun, July 25, https://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/14678780.Google Scholar
Asahi. 2022f. “Problems Over Money Continue at Unification Church: Lawyers.” Asahi Shimbun. July 13. https://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/14668795.Google Scholar
Asahi. 2022g. 旧統一教会、立憲が対策本部共 産も問題追及チーム [Former Unification Church, CDP's Task Force, and the Communist Party's Team to Pursue the Issue]. 朝日新聞 [Asahi Shinbun], 22 July. https://www.asahi.com/articles/DA3S15364514.html.Google Scholar
Asahi. 2022h. 超党派で調査、旧統一教会巡り弁護 士提言 [Nonpartisan Investigation, Lawyers'Recommendations over Former Unification Church]. 朝日新聞 [Asahi Shinbun], 27 July. https://www.asahi.com/articles/DA3S15369448.html.Google Scholar
Asahi. 2022i. 霊感商法、消費者庁が検討会月 内にも、河野氏が表明 [Spiritual Sales, Consumer Affairs Agency Will Hold a Study Group by the End of the Month, Kōno Announces]. 朝日新聞 [Asahi Shinbun], 13 August. https://www.asahi.com/articles/DA3S15386228.html.Google Scholar
Asahi. 2023a. “Unification Church Offers Apology, To Fight Dissolution Order.” Asahi Shimbun, 7 November. https://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/15050617.Google Scholar
Asahi. 2023b. “Former Followers Blast Unification Church Over Empty Apology.” Asahi Shimbun, 8 November. https://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/15051574.Google Scholar
Asahi. 2023c. “Victims Critical of New Law to Track Unification Church Assets.” Asahi Shimbun, 14 December, https://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/15083818.Google Scholar
Asahi Journal朝日ジャーナルed. 1987. 霊感商法： 追及ルポ [Spiritual Sales: A Follow-Up Reportage]. Asahi Booklet n. 86. Tokyo: Asahi.Google Scholar
Consumer Affairs Agency 消費者庁. 2019. 令和兀 年版消費者白書 [White Paper on Consumer Affairs 2079]. https://www.caa.go.jp/policies/policy/consumerresearch/whitepaper/assets/2019whitepaperall210608.pdf.Google Scholar
Economic Planning Agency 経済企画庁 ed. 1985. 代に向けて [1985 White Paper on National Life — 40 years After the War: Towards An Era of Maturity]. Tokyo: Ministry of Finance.Google Scholar
Expert Panel Tasked to Review the Current and Future State of Consumer Law消費者法の現状を 検証し将来の在り方を考える有識者懇談会. 2023. 消費者法の現状を検証し将来の在り方を考える： 有識者懇談会における議論の整理 [Reviewing the Current State of Consumer Law and Considering its Future: Summary of the Discussions of the Expert Panel] https://www.cao.go.jp/consumer/kabusoshiki/paradigmshift/doc/001_231227sankou4.pdf.Google Scholar
Fujimori, Ken 藤森研 1987a. 錬金術の“源流”を歩 く [A Walk Through the Origins of the Alchemy]. 朝日ジャーナル [Asahi Jānaru] 29(13), 18–21.Google Scholar
Fujimori, Ken 藤森研. 1987b. 爆発的な反響、霊感 商法の被害相談 [Explosive Response: Consultation on Spiritual Sales.] 朝日ジャーナル [Asahi Jānaru] 29(8), 106.Google Scholar
Fujiwara, Satoko 藤原聖子 ed. 2023. 日本人無宗教 言説：その歴史からみえるもの [Discourseon japanese Non-Religiousness: What History Can Show Us]. Tokyo: Chikuma Shobō.Google ScholarPubMed
Gaitanidis, Ioannis (forthcoming). “The Co-constitution of Bad Religion and Unethical Sales: Fear at the Heart of Japan's ‘Spiritual Sales.’” Implicit Religion.Google Scholar
Ishizuka, Yuto 石塚雄人. 1986. 「真理の友教会」集 団自殺事件を歩く [A Walk Through the Mass-Suicide Case of the Church of the Friends of Truth]. 朝日ジャーナル [Asahi Jānaru] 28(53), 22–23.Google Scholar
Isomae, Ju'ichi 機前順一. 2003. 近代日本の宗教 言説とその系譜:宗教·国家·神道 [Discourse on Religion and Its Genealogy in Modern Japan: Religion, Nation, Shinto]. Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten.Google ScholarPubMed
Itō, Masataka 伊藤正孝 and Fujimori, Ken 藤森研. 1986a. 全国調査:霊感商法の巨大な被害 [National Survey: The Huge Damage of Spiritual Sales]. 朝日ジャーナル [Asahi Jānaru] 28(50), 6–13.Google ScholarPubMed
Itō, Masataka 伊藤正孝 and Fujimori, Ken 藤森研. 1986b. 霊感商法のあくなき食欲 [The Relentless Appetite of the Spiritual Sales]. 朝日ジャーナル [Asahi Jānaru] 28 (53), 14–21.Google Scholar
Josephson, Jason A. 2012. The Invention of Religion in Japan. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kirsch, Thomas G. and Turner, Bertram. 2009. Permutations of Order: Religion and Law as Contested Sovereignties. London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Kitō, Masaki 紀藤正樹. 2017. 決定版マインド·コ ントロール [The Definitive Guide to Mind Control]. Tokyo: Ascom.Google Scholar
Kitō, Masaki 紀藤正. 2018. 霊感商法を規制する消 費者契約法改正案が成立 [Proposed Amendment to the Consumer Contract Law to Regulate “Spiritual Sales” Passed]. 消費者法ニュース [Consumer Law News] 117, 64–65.Google Scholar
Kodama, Tetsuaki 児玉哲明. 1990. 心の渇きつく商 法は滅びない [A Business That Thirsts for Hearts and Minds Will Not Perish]. 朝日ジャーナル [Arahi Jānaru] 32(39), 21.Google Scholar
Larsson, Ernils. 2020. “Rituals of a Secular Nation: Shinto Normativity and the Separation of Religion and State in Postwar Japan.” PhD dissertation, Uppsala University.Google Scholar
Miyashita, Shūichi 宮下修一,Yō Terakawa 寺川永， Takafumi Matsuda 松田貴文，Sachiyo Maki 牧佐智 代,Antonios Karaiskos. 2022. 消費者法 [Consumer Law]. Tokyo: Yukihaku Studia.Google Scholar
NCAC, National Consumer Affairs Centre of Japan び多宝塔に関する調査結果 [Results of Survey on Seals, Marble Vases and Polychrome Pagodas]. 月間 国民生活 [National Life Monthly] 13(6), 48–49.Google Scholar
Oraby, Mona and Sullivan, Winnifred Fallers. 2020. “Law and Religion: Reimagining the Entanglement of Two Universals.” Annual Review of Law and Social Science 16: 257–276.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
RCLN, Religion and Consumers Lawyers’ Network 目による悪徳商法 [Malicious business Practices in the Name of Religion]. Tokyo: Ryokufu Shuppan.Google Scholar
Saitō Masami. “The Abe Assassination, the Unification Church, and Local Media: A Case Study of Journalism in Toyama Prefecture.” Asia Pacific Journal: Japan Focus 11(10) no. 4, https://www.apjjf.org/2024/10/saito.Google Scholar
Sullivan, Winnifred Fallers, Hurd, Elizabeth Shakman, Mahmood, Saba and Danchin, Peter G.. 2015. Politics of Religious Freedom. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
StopReikan. 2022. National Network of Lawyers Association Against Spiritual Sales. https://www.stopreikan.com/english/index-e.htm.Google Scholar
Tanimoto, Keiko 谷本圭子, Toshiya Bandō 坂東俊 矢 and Karaiskos, Antonios. 2020. これからの消費 者法:社会と未来をつなぐ消費者教育 [Consumer Law: Present and Future]. Tokyo: Hōritsu Bunkasha.Google ScholarPubMed
Takahara, Kanako. 2022. “Kishida Cabinet Approves Bill Banning Use of Fear to Solicit Donations.” The Japan Times,1 December, https://www.japan-times.co.jp/news/2022/12/01/national/cabinet-approves-donations-fear-bill/.Google Scholar
Thomas, Jolyon B. 2019. Faking Liberties: Religious Freedom in American-Occupied Japan. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
TMPD, Tokyo Metropolitan Police Department 警視庁. 2016. 霊感商法 [spiritual Sales]. https://www.keismcho.metro.tokyo.lg.jp/kurashi/higai/shoho/reikan.html.Google Scholar
Yamaguchi, Hiroshi 山口広. 1993. 検証·統一協 会：霊感商法の実態 [Investigation: the Unification Church: The Reality of Spiritual Sales]. Tokyo: Ryokufu Shuppan.Google ScholarPubMed
Yamaguchi, Hiroshi 山口広. 1996. 宗教活動から 生じる消費者問題とその対策 [Consumer Problems Arising from Religious Activities and Their Counter-measures]. 宗教法 [Religious Law] 15, 217–253.Google Scholar
Yamaguchi, Hiroshi 山口広. 2017. 検証·統一教会 =家庭連合:霊感商法·世界平和統一家庭連合の 実態 [Investigation: the Unification Church-Family Federation. Spiritual Sales and the Reality of the Family Federation for World Peace and Unification]. Tokyo: Ryokufū Shuppan.Google ScholarPubMed
Yamaguchi, Hiroshi 山口広，Masaki Kitō 紀藤正樹 and Takimoto, Tarō 滝本太郎. 1999. Q&A宗教トラブ ル110番：しのびよるカルト [Q&A for Police Emergencies About Troubles With Religion: Creeping Cults]. Tokyo: Mınjihō Kenkyūkai.Google Scholar
Yamaguchi, Hiroshi 山口広，Hiroshi Hirata 平田広 志，Shuji Nakamura 中村周而,and Masaki Kitō 紀 藤正. 2000. カルト宗教のトラブル対策：日本と欧米 の実情と取り組み [Countermeasures Against Cult Issues: Current Situations and initiatives in Japan, Europe and the United States]. Tokyo: Kyōiku Shiryō Shuppankai.Google ScholarPubMed
Yamaguchi, Hiroshi 山口広，Makoto Sataka 佐高 信, Yasuo Kawai川井康雄,Katsuomi Abe阿部克 臣,Sou Kimura 木村壮,Ryō Nakagawa 中川亮 and Kubouchi, Hirotsugu 久保内浩嗣. 2022. 統一教会との闘い 35年、そしてこれから [The 35-year Struggle Against the Unification Church: Looking Into the Future] Tokyo: Junpōsha.Google Scholar
Zenkoku reikan shōhō taisaku bengoshi renrakukai 全国霊感商法対策弁護士連絡会, Zenkoku genriundō higaisha chichihaha no kai 全国原涅運動被 害者父母の会,Nihon kirisutokyōdan tōitsu genri mondai renrakukai日本基督教団統一原涅問題 連絡. 1997. 統一協会合同結婚式の手口と実態 [The Modus Operandi and Reality of the Unification Church's Mass Weddings]. Tokyo: Ryokufū Shuppan.Google Scholar
You have
Access