Hostname: page-component-7b9c58cd5d-wdhn8 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2025-03-17T12:26:12.360Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Comparative Reflections on the Carlos Ghosn Case and Japanese Criminal Justice

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 March 2025

Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Core share and HTML view are not available for this content. However, as you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

The arrest and prosecution of Nissan executive Carlos Ghosn, together with his dramatic flight from Japan, have focused unprecedented attention on Japan's criminal justice system. This article employs comparison with the United States to examine issues in Japanese criminal justice highlighted by the Ghosn case. The criminal charges and procedures used in Ghosn's case illustrate several serious weaknesses in Japanese criminal justice—including the problems of prolonged detention and interrogation without a defense attorney that have been characterized as “hostage justice.” But in comparative perspective, the criminal justice systems in Japan and the U. S. have some striking similarities. Most notably, both systems rely on coercive means to obtain admissions of guilt, and both systems have high conviction rates. The American counterpart to Japan's use of high-pressure tactics to obtain confessions is a system of plea bargaining in which prosecutors use the threat of a large “trial tax” (a longer sentence for defendants who insist upon their right to a trial and are then convicted) to obtain guilty pleas. An apples-to-apples comparison also indicates that Japan's “99% conviction rate” is not the extreme outlier that it is often said to be. Commentary on Ghosn's case emphasized the weaknesses in Japanese criminal justice. Those weaknesses are real and important, but by many criteria, such as crime and incarceration rates, Japan outperforms the U.S. As for Ghosn's case in particular, this article explores four scenarios of what might have happened to him if his case had occurred in the U.S. It is not obvious that he would have fared better under American law, nor is it obvious that justice would have been better realized.

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © The Authors 2020

References

Abdallah, Issam and Kelly, Tim. 2019. “Ghosn says he Escaped ‘Injustice’ in Japan; Lebanon Calls Arrival a Private Matter.” Reuters, December 30, at https://www.reuters.com/article/us-renault-nissan-ghosn-lebanon/ghosn-says-he-escaped-injustice-in-japan-lebanon-calls-arrival-a-private-matter-idUSKBN1YY1FM.Google Scholar
Aronson, Bruce E. 2019. “Chapter 10: Japan,” in Aronson, Bruce and Kim, Joongi, editors, Corporate Governance in Asia: A Comparative Approach, pp. 267296. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Aronson, Bruce E., Kozuka, Souichiro and Nottage, Luke. 2016. “Corporate Legislation in Japan,” in Haghirian, Parissa, editor, Routledge Handbook of Japanese Business and Management, pp. 103113. London and New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
Press, Associated. 2018. “Carlos Ghosn's Detention puts Japan's Justice System under Microscope,” CNBC, December 23.Google Scholar
Press, Associated. 2020. “France Steps Up Investigation around Carlos Ghosn and Omani Car Dealership.” February 19, at.Google Scholar
Boudette, Neal E. 2020. “Carlos Ghosn and the Roots of Nissan's Decline.” New York Times, January 15.Google Scholar
Burns, Robert P. 2009. The Death of the American Trial. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Campbell, Matthew et al. 2020. “How Carlos Ghosn Became the World's Most Famous Fugitive.” Bloomberg, January 6.Google Scholar
Coffee, John C. Jr. 2020. Corporate Crime and Punishment: The Crisis of Underenforcement. Oakland, CA: Berrett-Koehler Publishers, Inc.Google Scholar
Coleman, James William. 2002. The Criminal Elite: Understanding White-Collar Crime. New York: Worth Publishers.Google Scholar
Congressional Research Service. 2019. Mail and Wire Fraud: A Brief Overview of Federal Criminal Law. February 11.Google Scholar
Croydon, Silvia. 2016. The Politics of Police Detention in Japan: Consensus of Convenience. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ben, Dooley. 2019a. “Carlos Ghosn Hasn't Seen his Wife in Months. Japan's Prosecutors Want it that Way.” New York Times, August 7.Google Scholar
Dooley, Ben. 2019b. “Ghosn Team Not Allowed to Review Nissan Files.” New York Times, October 25.Google Scholar
Eisinger, Jesse. 2017. The Chickenshit Club: Why the Justice Department Fails to Prosecute Executives. New York: Simon & Schuster.Google Scholar
Ezoe, Hiromasa. 2010. Where Is the Justice? Media Attacks, Prosecutorial Abuse, and My 13 Years in Japanese Court. Tokyo: Kodansha.Google Scholar
Fair Trials (an international human rights organization). 2016. “The Disappearing Trial: Towards a Rights-Based Approach to Trial Waiver Systems”, pp. 182.Google Scholar
Financial Services Agency. 2010. “Cabinet Office Ordinance on Partial Amendment of the Cabinet Office Ordinance on Disclosure of Corporate Information, etc. (2010 Cabinet Office Ordinance No. 12).”.Google Scholar
Fisher, George. 2003. Plea Bargaining's Triumph: A History of Plea Bargaining in America. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Foote, Daniel H. 1991. “Confessions and the Right to Silence in Japan.” Georgia Journal of International & Comparative Law. Vol. 21, pp. 415488.Google Scholar
Foote, Daniel H. 1993. “Policing in Japan” [book review of Setsuo Miyazawa's Policing in Japan: A Study on Making Crime, 1992]. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, Vol. 84, no. 2 (summer), pp. 410427.Google Scholar
Foote, Daniel H. 2010. “Policymaking by the Japanese Judiciary in the Criminal Justice Field.” Japanese Journal of Legal Sociology [Hoshakaigaku], No. 72, pp. 645.Google Scholar
Garland, David. 2020. “Penal Controls and Social Controls: Toward a Theory of American Penal Exceptionalism.” Punishment & Society, Vol. 22, No. 3 (July), pp. 321352.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Garrett, Brandon. 2014. Too Big to Jail: How Prosecutors Compromise with Corporations. Cambridge, MA: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Gevurtz, Franklin. 2006. Global Issues in Corporate Law. St. Paul, MN: Thomson/West.Google Scholar
Goto, Akira et al. (panel discussion, part 2). 2020. “Ghosn Jiken Bengoshi Jimusho no Sosaku Sashiosae to Oshu Kyozetsu.”.Google Scholar
Hodgson, Jacqueline S. 2020. The Metamorphosis of Criminal Justice: A Comparative Account. New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Homusho [Japan's Ministry of Justice], 2012. “Torishirabe ni kan suru Kokunai Chosa Kekka Hokokusho.” August, pp. 195.Google Scholar
Horie, Masatsugu. 2020. “Nissan Sues Ghosn in Japan, Seeks $91 Million in Damages.” Bloomberg, February 12.Google Scholar
Howard, Marc Morje. 2017. Unusually Cruel: Prisons, Punishment, and the Real American Exceptionalism. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Ibusuki, Makoto. 2020. “Nihongata Shiho Torihiki Seido no Gaiyo to Nissan Jidosha Jiken kara Mita Unyojo no Mondaiten.” Bujinesu Homu, July, pp. 141146.Google Scholar
Ibusuki, Makoto, and Repeta, Lawrence. 2020. “The Reality of the ‘Right to Counsel’ in Japan and the Lawyers' Campaign to Change It.” The Asia-Pacific Journal/Japan Focus, Vol. 18, Issue 13, No. 4, pp. 111.Google Scholar
Inoue, Makiko, Yamamitsu, Eimi and Gall, Carlotta. 2020. “Japan Issues Arrest Warrant for Carlos Ghosn's Wife.” New York Times, January 7.Google Scholar
Press, Jiji. 2019. “Plea Deal Talks with Nissan Executives over Ghosn Charges began Month prior to his Arrest.” Japan Times, March 10.Google Scholar
Press, Jiji. 2020. “Panel Upholds Decision not to Indict Ex-Nissan Chief Hiroto Saikawa.” Japan Times, January 28.Google Scholar
Johnson, David T. 2002. The Japanese Way of Justice: Prosecuting Crime in Japan. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Johnson, David T. 2017. “The Best Defense Lawyer in Japan” [“Nihon no Saiko no Keiji Bengonin”]. In Akira, Kitani, Seiho, Cho, Kyoko, Yoshida, and Iwao, Takayama, editors, Kempo teki Keiji Bengo: Bengoshi Takano Takashi no Jissen [Constitutional Criminal Defense: The Practices of Defense Lawyer Takano Takashi]. Tokyo: Nihon Hyoronsha, pp. 225240.Google Scholar
Johnson, David T. 2018. “Comparative Reflections on American Crime Declines.” Berkeley Journal of Criminal Law. Vol. 23, No. 2, pp. 2545.Google Scholar
Johnson, David T., Fukurai, Hiroshi, and Hirayama, Mari. 2020. “Reflections on the Tepco Trial: Prosecution and Acquittal after Japan's Nuclear Meltdown.” Asia-Pacific Journal/Japan Focus, Vol. 18, Issue 2, No. 1 (January 15), pp. 136.Google Scholar
Johnson, Nicholas. 2019. “Ghosn, Yamashiro, and the United Nations – Japan's Coercive Police Practices in the International Spotlight.” The Asia-Pacific Journal/Japan Focus, Vol. 17, Issue 19, No. 4, pp. 15.Google Scholar
Keisatsucho [Japan's National Police Agency], 2012. “Keisatsu ni okeru Torishirabe no Jitsujo ni tsuite.” October, pp. 111, at.Google Scholar
Konishi, Yusuke. 2019. “Ghosn Case looks to Shake up Japan's ‘Hostage Justice’.” Nikkei Asian Review, March 7.Google Scholar
Kostov, Nick and McLain, Sean. 2019. “Nissan Probes Whether Ghosn Channeled Company Money for Personal Use.” Wall Street Journal, April 3.Google Scholar
Kurabe, Yosuke, Yamada, Kaoru and Yuzawa, Masahisa. 2018. “Prosecutors Sharpen Offensive on Ghosn with New Allegations: Ex-chairman Suspected of Arranging $15m Nissan Payment to Cover Personal Losses.” Nikkei Asian Review, December 22.Google Scholar
News, Kyodo. 2019a. “Ghosn Charged with Aggravated Breach of Trust over Nissan Allegations; Lawyers Launch Long-shot Bail Bid.” Japan Times, January 11.Google Scholar
News, Kyodo. 2019b. “Nissan CEO Hiroto Saikawa Won't be Charged over Ghosn's Underreported Pay, Sources say.” Japan Times, May 17.Google Scholar
News, Kyodo. 2019c. “Ghosn's Lawyers Renew Criticism of Japan's Judicial System.” Nikkei Asian Review, November 19.Google Scholar
Langbein, John. 1978. “Torture and Plea Bargaining.” University of Chicago Law Review. Vol. 46, No. 3, pp. 322.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leo, Richard A. 1996. “Inside the Interrogation Room.” Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, Vol. 86, No. 2, pp. 266303.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Leo, Richard A. 2008. Police Interrogation and American Justice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lynch, Mona. 2016. Hard Bargains: The Coercive Power of Drug Laws in Federal Court. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
Lynch, Timothy. 2003. “The Case against Plea Bargaining.” Regulation, Fall issue, pp. 2427.Google Scholar
Ma, Jie and Horie, Masatsugu. 2016. “Nissan Seals $2.3 Billion Mitsubishi Motors Stake Acquisition.” Bloomberg, October 20.Google Scholar
Mann, Kenneth. 1985. Defending White-Collar Crime: A Portrait of Attorneys at Work. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
McLain, Sean. 2019. “Nissan Ousts CEO Saikawa as Car Maker Seeks to Revive Business.” Wall Street Journal, September 9.Google Scholar
Milken, John P. and Fu, Dean. 2005The Global Leadership of Carlos Ghosn at Nissan.” Thunderbird International Law Review Vol. 47, No. 1, pp. 121137, Jan.-Feb.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Miyazawa, Setsuo. 1992. Policing in Japan: A Study on Making Crime. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.Google Scholar
Morck, Randall and Nakamura, Masao. 2007. “A Frog in a Well Knows Nothing of the Ocean: a History of Corporate Ownership in Japan,” in A History of Corporate Governance around the World, Randall Morck, editor, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Motivans, Mark, Bureau of Justice Statistics, U.S. Department of Justice. 2019. Federal Justice Statistics, 20152016.Google Scholar
Naito, Edo. 2019. “Examining Carlos Ghosn and Japan's system of ‘hostage justice’” Japan Times, April 17.Google Scholar
Natapoff, Alexandra. 2011. Snitching: Criminal Informants and the Erosion of American Justice. New York University Press.Google Scholar
Neily, Clark. 2019. “Prisons are Packed Because Prosecutors Are Coercing Plea Deals. And Yes, It's Totally Legal.” Wall Street Journal, August 8.Google Scholar
Nelken, David. 2010. Comparative Criminal Justice. London: Sage.Google Scholar
Nikkei, . 2018. “Ghosn and Prosecutors Battle over Validity of Top Secret Documents.” Nikkei Asian Review, December 1.Google Scholar
Nissan Motor Co., Ltd.. 2020. “Improvement Measures Status Report” (submitted to Tokyo Stock Exchange as ordered by the Exchange), January 16,.Google Scholar
Nissan Motor Corporation. 2020. “Nissan Seeks 10 billion yen in Damages from Former Chairman Carlos Ghosn over Misconduct and Fraudulent Activity.”.Google Scholar
Nissan Motor Corporation Global Website. 2020. “Company Development/Heritage.”.Google Scholar
Ohno, Kotaro. 2020. “Kigyo to Shiho Torihiki.” International Civil and Commercial Law Center News, Vol. 70 (May), pp. 323.Google Scholar
Rakoff, Jed. 2014. “Why Innocent People Plead Guilty.” New York Review of Books, November 20.Google Scholar
Reuters, , 2020. “‘Make Yourself Invaluable’: Carlos Ghosn Offers Executive Training in Troubled Lebanon.” The Asahi Shimbun/Asia & Japan Watch, September 30.Google Scholar
Saiki, Shoko and Konishi, Yusuke. 2018. “Prosecutors Press Ghosn over ‘Fixed Remuneration’ Document.” Nikkei Asian Review, December 19.Google Scholar
Sebag, Gaspard and Patel, Tara. 2020. “Ghosn says French Investigators will Quiz him in Lebanon in 2021,” Bloomberg, November 2.Google Scholar
Securities and Exchange Commission. 2019. Complaint, United States Securities and Exchange Commission v. Carlos Ghosn and Gregory L. Kelly, No. 1: 19-CV-08798 (Southern District of New York, Sept. 23, 2019).Google Scholar
Supreme Court of Japan. 2019. Outline of Criminal Justice in Japan 2019.Google Scholar
Tabuchi, Hiroko. 2013. “Suspended Sentences in Olympus Fraud Case.” New York Times, July 3.Google Scholar
Takano, Takashi. 2006 – present. “Keiji Saiban o Kangaeru: Takano Takashi @ Burogu.”.Google Scholar
Takano, Takashi. 2019. “Hostage Justice System in Japan: How It Works, and Why?” Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Asian Law & Society Association in Osaka, December 14.Google Scholar
Tanaka, Akito. 2018. “After Ghosn, Auto Alliance Faces Uncertain Future: Tensions between Renault and Nissan Burst into Open.” Nikkei Asian Review, November 28.Google Scholar
Taub, Jennifer. 2020. Big Dirty Money: The Shocking Injustice and Unseen Cost of White Collar Crime. New York: Viking.Google Scholar
Truong, Alice. 2018. “Carlos Ghosn is up against Japan's 99.9% Conviction Rate.” Quartz, December 10.Google Scholar
Wall Street Journal Editorial Board. 2020. “Ghosn, Baby, Ghosn.” January 9.Google Scholar
Woodford, Michael. 2012. Exposure: Inside the Olympus Scandal: How I Went from CEO to Whistleblower. New York: Portfolio/Penguin.Google Scholar
Yaffe-Bellany, David. 2020. “Ghosn Says Escape Accomplices Would Face Abuse in Japan.” Bloomberg, November 10.Google Scholar
Yamashita, Terutoshi. 2020. “Is Japanese Criminal Justice Still in the Middle Ages?” Asia Crime Prevention Foundation Mail Magazine (4 parts).Google Scholar