Thus noted Carlyle of Catherine Kirkpatrick, the daughter of James Achilles Kirkpatrick, resident of Hyderabad, and the Begum Khair-un-nissa, a noblewoman of the court at Hyderabad. As Carlyle remarked, there was something strangely endearing about the woman he knew as Kitty: “she was charming in her beautiful begum sort.” She was not very clever, not very witty but she was “amiable,” affectionate, sensuous, and loved perfumes. In assessing her character, Carlyle concluded that she was a “half-begum in short; an interesting specimen of the Semi-oriental Englishwoman.” Carlyle's description evokes a sense of oriental romance: because Kitty was born of nobility, because she was the product of a love affair between an Indian noblewoman and a British official, Kitty was charmed in a way that was sublime. Through this characterization, Carlyle expressed what others would note about elite mixed-race men and women who went from India to Britain: that although they spoke English and lived as Europeans, their manners and appearance marked them out as being not quite Brit.